Файл: Дрёмов С.В., Сёмин И.Р. - Измененные состояния сознания.pdf
ВУЗ: Не указан
Категория: Не указан
Дисциплина: Не указана
Добавлен: 10.10.2020
Просмотров: 2746
Скачиваний: 8
106
6/88-6.+2
,
+ 4@7R-6.
,
4/=8541/
/1./8/=+9-46/0
5*=@,-1.5F++
,
1-
,/=@.
1-
+43G.G25.A
42;C511@H
4 E.+,
.*-2/=@
.
3/./,@
+1D+2+D@58A1G-
+ 6/88-6.+21G-
3*-D4.528-1+;
-
2G4<+0
3*/D@6.
4/F+58A1/0
I+C1+
-
3/
4@.+
,
-4.A
4*-D4.2/
--
3-*-I+251+;
-
.*514
-
B/*,5F++
2 *-8+=+/C1/-
9@24.2/
+8+
4/F+58+C+*/2511G-
E,/F++
.
56+,
/7*5C/,
,
1-4,/.*;
15
B/*,58A1@H
*5C1/*/D1/4.A
+1D+2+D@58A1G:
+ 6/88-6.+21G:
3*-D4.52
-
8-1+0
,
,G
154.5+25-,
15
+:
E.+/8/=+9-46/,
+ B@16F+/158A1/,
4:/D4.2-
.
/3*/4
/ 43-F+B+6-
E.1+9-46/0
34+:/8/=++
C56/1/,-*1/
3/;2+84;
2 45,/,
15958-
C5*/ID-1+;
1/2/0
D+4F+38+1G
.
/=D5
E.1+9-465;
34+:/8/=+;
-*75*.5
+ @1D.5
1-
2GD-*I585
6*+.+6+
4/
4./
-
*/1G
8+1=2+4./2
+ 1-
4,/=85
/3*-D-8+.A
42/-
43-F+B+9-46/-
8+F/
,
2 /44++
3/;2+854A
E.1/34+
-
:/8/=+;
.
'3-.5
.
3/+46-
3*-D,-.5
E.1/34+:/8/=++
'3-.
3*+CG258
/.8+95.A
*-C@8A.5.G
48+;1+;
34+:/8/=++
+1D+2+D/2
,
6/./*G-
,/=@.
3/65C5.A4;
4@.AH
6/88-6.+21/0
34+:/8/=++
,
/.
+4:/D1/0
4/
-
4.528;H?-0
E.1+9-46/0
34+:/8/=++
,
6/./*5;
,
4/74.2-11/
,
+ /7@48/28+25-.
43-F+B+6@
E./0
15@6+
.
*+2-D-,
+43/8AC/2511@H
=
.
'3-./,
(1996,
4
.99)
2GD-*I6@
+C
+,,-8;
: "
/=D5
./835
...
*5C*@<5-.
D/,
,
2G1/4+.
3*+=/2/*
,
+CD5-.
6*+6
,
CD-4A
4@,,+*@H.4;
D-04.2+;
/.D-8A1G:
4@7R-6./2
2 /D1/
3*/+4<-4.2+-
...
@.
-
./
+ 2/C1+65-.
2-8+6/-
4,-<-1+-
:
21-<1-
-D+1G0
*-C@8A.5.
,1/=+:
4@7R-6
-
.+21G:
D@<-21G:
3*/F-44/2
./86@-.4;
656
*-C@8A.5.
-D+1/=/
D@<-21/=/
3*/F-445
2 6/88-6.+21/0
D@<-
.
D+14.2/
*-C@8A.+*@H?-=/
;28-1+;
/.*5I5-.4;
15
3*-D3/85=5-,/-
-D+14.2/
-=/
34+:+9-
-
46/0
3*+9+1G
".
=
.
'3-.
3/;41;-.
: "
56
7G
1+
7G8+
8HD+
*5C8+91G
,
-4.A
.+3+9-46+
/7?--
2 +:
3-
-
*-I+251+;:
656
"
/.68+6
"
15
3*/+4:/D;?--
3-*-D
+:
=85C5,+
,
@,5,+
+ 4-*DF5,+
" (
.5,
I-
,
4
.110-
111).
4/7/
/1
3/D9-*6+25-.
,
9./
"
.56+-
/.68+6+
,
D@<-21/-
E:/
,
*5CD5H.4;
1-
./8A6/
15
=/8/45
+
*5CD*5I-1+;
,
+D@?+-
+C
/7R-6.+21/0
3*+*/D1/0
4*-DG
6/88-6.+25
+ +C
-=/
4/F+58A1/0
+ +4./*+
-
9-46/0
/74.51/26+
,
1/
/1+
2G*5I5H.
.56I-
-=/
D@<-21/-
/.1/<-1+-
6 3/1;.+;,
+ +D-;,
...
3*-D
-
4./;?+,
+1D+2+D@
+ 6/88-6.+2@
".
4:/D;
+C
3/8/I-1+0=
.
'3-.5
,
5 .56I-
+C
3*-D8/I-11/0
+1.-*
-
3*-.5F++
3*-D4.528-1+0
656
4B-*G
,
.*514B/*,+*@H?-0
.*-2/=@
,
4B/*,@8+*@-,
15<-
3/1+,51+-
./=/
F-8/=/
,
9./
/7R-D+1;-.
6/88-6.+2
+ 4/4.528;-.
/41/21/0
3*-D,-.
E.1+9-46/0
34+:/8/=++
.
5
3-*2G0
3851
,G
2GD2+=5-,
6/88-6.+21@H
3/.*-71/4.A
2 45,//3*-D-8-1++
+ 45,/@.2-*ID-1++
-
3/.*-71/4.A
2 E6C+4.-1F+58A1/0
C5?+?-11/4.+
.
15
3*+4@.4.2@-.
15
3*/.;I-1++
24-=/
E2/8HF+
-
/11/=/
3@.+
*5C2+.+;
4/C151+;
+ /4@?-4.28;-.4;
785=/D5*;
*5C2+.+H
*5C8+91G:
.+3/2
3/C151+;
-
9@24.2-11/=/
,
1-3/4*-D4.2-11/
42;C511/=/
4 EBB-6.+21/4.AH
(
*-8+=+/C1/-
3/C151+-
),
E,3+*+9-
-
46/=/
(
15@65
)
+ B+8/4/B46/=/
,
:5*56.-*
6/./*/=/
C52+4+.
/.
6/16*-.1/0
4+4.-,G
B+8/4/B4.2/25
-
1+;
(
+D-58+4.+9-46+0
+ ,5.-*+58+4.+9-46+0
/7R-6.+2+C,
,
3/C+.+2+C,
,
51.*/3/8/=+9-465;
B+8/
-
4/B+;
,
E6C+4.-1F+58+C,
,
:/8+4.+9-46+-
4+4.-,G
).
*/+88H4.*+*@-,
465C511/-
2 4:-,-
,
2G*5I5H?-0
*5C2+.+-
6/88-6.+21/=/
4/C151+;
(
*+4
.1).
+,46+,+
F+B*5,+
2 D511/0
4:-,-
/7/C159-1G
.*+
E3+4.-,G
,
+8+
3/C1525.-8A1G-
3*/4.*514.25
,
-
456*58A1/-
,
42-.46/-
+ *-8+=+/C1/-
.
8521G,
/41/251+-,
D8;
+:
4/3/4.528-1+;
+ 3*/.+2/3/4
-
.528-1+;
;28;-.4;
/4/7-11/4.A
2C5+,/D-04.2+;
4 ,+*/,
.
56*58A1/-
=1/4-/8/=+9-46/-
3*/
-
4.*514.2/
(I)
/.8+95-.4;
4+16*-.+C,/,
+**5F+/158A1G:
+ *5F+/158A1G:
E8-,-1./2
.
D-+
,
/7*5CG
/7R-6./2
1-3/4*-D4.2-11/
C52+4;.
/.
5BB-6./2
(
4.*54.-0
),
6/./*G-
2GCG25H.
E.+
+D-+
+ /7*5CG
.
3*-D-8;H?-0
9-*./0
456*58A1/=/
=1/4-/8/=+9-46/=/
3*/4.*514.25
49+.5-.4;
-=/
D+BB@C1/4.A
,
6/./*5;
3*/;28;-.4;
2 1-/.9-.8+2/4.+
3*/.+2/3/4.528-1+;
4@7R-6.5
+ /7R-6.5
,
I+2/=/
+ ,-*.2/
-
=/
,
3*+9+1G
+ 48-D4.2+;
,
/C1595-,/=/
+ C159-1+;
,
2-?+
+ 48/25
.
*+
.56/,
43/4/7-
@42/-1+;
,+
-
*5
24-
2 1-,
/65CG25-.4;
42;C511G,
. "
54.A
@3/D/78;-.4;
F-8/,@
,
*5C8+91G-
;28-1+;
*544,5.
-
*+25H.4;
656
/D+156/2G-
.
8-,-1.G
,
3*+28-65-,G-
D8;
/3+451+;
/6*@I5H?-=/
,+*5
,
/785D5H.
,1/=/C1591/4.AH
" (
507@*+1
, 1991
5
,
4
.179).
107
56
6@8A.@*15;
58A.-*15.+25
E.+,
=8/758A1G,
2C5+,/42;C;,
*5C2+25-.4;
.+3
,G<8-1+;
,
/41/
-
2511G0
15
3*+9+11/
-
48-D4.2-11G:
/.1/<-1+;:
-
42-.46/-
=1/4-/8/=+9-46/-
3*/4.*514.2/
(II).
-,
7/8A<-=/
*5C2+.+;
D/4.+=5-.
/7?-4.2/
15
3@.+
15@91/=/
+ B+8/4/B46/=/
3*/42-.+.-8A4.25
,
9-,
7/8--
+C/8+*/2511/0
4.51/2+.4;
E.5
"
3*/4-65
"
9-8/2-9-46/=/
3/C151+;
,
.-,
/.9-.8+2-0
2G*5I-
-
1G
3*/.+2/3/8/I1/4.+
/7R-6.+21/
3/C1525-,/=/
+ ,-.5B+C+9-46/=/
4@7R-6.+21/=/
,
+:
4/+C,-*+
-
,/4.A
+ 2 6/1-91/,
+./=-
1-*5CD-8+,/4.A
.
544,5.*+25;
*5C2+.+-
3/C151+;
2 F-8/,
,
2/
24-:
-=/
4*-D4.25:
+ F-8;:
,
,G
3*-D3/9+.5-,
15
-
C25.A
.*-.A-
3*/4.*514.2/
4:-,G
/7854.AH
*-8+=+/C1/=/
3*/4.*514.25
(III).
511/-
/7/C159-1+-
+,--.
46/*--
34+:/8/=+9-46+0
,
9-,
6@8A./2/
-
.-/8/=+9-46+0
4,G48
+ 42;C51/
4 E.+,/8/=+-0
48/25
"
*-8+=+;
".
E./,
=1/4-/8/=+9-46/,
3*/4.*514.2-
3*/+4:/D+.
,
656
3+458
.
+6€*
(1996), "
5.565
15
*-8+=+H
15
--
4/74.2-11/0
.-**+./*++
".
5F+/158+4.+9-46+-
+4.+1G
,
2 ./,
9+48-
*-8+=+/C1G-
D/=,5.G
,
4//.1/4;.4;
4 F-11/4.1G,
+C,-*-1+-,
,
/7R-6.1G-
/.1/<-1+;
3/C+.+2+4.46/=/
3/C151+;
D/3/81;H.4;
+1.@+.+21G,
,
9@24.2-11G,
3*/1+61/2-1+-,
2 ,+*
D*@=/=/
4@7R-6.5
.
56+,
/7*5C/,
,
/3*-D-8-1+-,
.*-.A-=/
=1/4-/8/=+9-46/=/
3*/4.*514.25
,G
@*521/2-<+25-,
3*/42-.+.-8A46@H
,-.5B/*@
/=/45
3*+1F+3/,
2C5+,/42;C511/4.+
24-=/
2 */4-
,
5 2 -D+14.2-
42-.46/=/
+ *-8+=+
-
/C1/=/
3*/4.*514.2
B/*,+*@-,
6@8A.@*B+8/4/B46@H
51.+.-C@
456*58A1/,@
3*/4.*514.2@
3/C15
-
1+;
.
7/C159+2
24-
=1/4-/8/=+9-46+-
/7854.+
,
,G
,/I-,
*544,5.*+25.A
E2/8HF+H
6/88-6.+21/=/
4/C
-
151+;
2 51.*/3/8/=+9-46/,
68H9-
.
5C2+.+-
@*/21-0
4/C151+;
5
-
- D511/0
4:-,G
*544,5.*+25-.4;
656
*5C2+.+-
43/4/7/2
3*-/D/8-1+;
.*-2/=+
-
D/4.+I-1+-
6/88-6.+21G,
4@7R-6./,
E6C+4.-1F+
-
58A1/0
C5?+?-11/4.+
.
.*-86/0
,
4/-D+1;H?-0
3@16.G
1
+
3,
/7/C159-1/
/41/21/-
153*528-1+-
*5C2+.+;
6/88-6.+21/=/
4/C151+;
/.
+4:/D1/=/
4/4./;1+;
D+BB@C1/4.+
+ 4+16*-.+91/4.+
6 3/;2
-
8-1+H
3*/.+2/3/4.528-1+0
+ 52./1/,1/4.+
+ D58--
6 D+58-6.+9-46/,@
41;.+H
3*/.+2/3/4.528-
-
1+0
2 4/2*-,-11G:
B+8/4/B46+:
4+4.-,5:
,
*-8+=+/C1G:
D/6.*+15:
+ ,-ID+4F+38+15*1G:
15@9
-
1G:
3/D:/D5:
.
*+25;
0-1-2
4//.2-.4.2@-.
*5C2+.+H
,+B/8/=+9-46/=/
4/C151+;
.
1-<1--
+ 21@.*-11--
,
4@7R-6
-
.+21/-
+ /7R-6.+21/-
,
74/8H.
(
/D@:/.2/*-115;
*+*/D5
)
+ 9-8/2-9-46+0
,+*
48+.G
2 -D+1/,
,+B/8/=+9-46/,
3*/4.*514.2-
456*58A1/=/
(I).
56
2+D1/
+C
4:-,G
,
3/;28-1+H
E6C+4.-1F+58A1/=/
@*/21;
6/88-6.+21/=/
4/C151+;
(
4
),
2/C1+61/2-1+H
E6C+4.-1F+58A1G:
3*/.+2/3/4.528-1+0
6/88-6
-
.+21/=/
4@7R-6.5
+ /41/251+0
D8;
4/F+58A1/0
I+C1+
(II)
3*-D<-4.2@H.
*5C2+.+-
./.-,+4.+9-46/=/
(a)
+ 51+,+4.+9-46/=/
(b)
@*/21-0
4/C151+;
.
3@16.5
2
*5C2+.+-
6/88-6.+21/=/
4/C151+;
4/3*/2/
-
ID5-.4;
E,3+*+9-46+,+
2/38/?-1+;,+
6/88-6.+21/=/
4@7R-6.5
2 D-;.-8A1/4.1/0
4B-*-
.
,-4.-
4 E.+,
3*/+4:/D+.
B@16F+/158A15;
D+BB-*-1F+5F+;
.+3/2
3/C151+;
.
!+8/4/B46/-
3/C151+-
2
4//.2-.4.2@H?+:
*5C1G,
B+8/4/B46+,
4+4.-,5,
,-./D5:
/3*-D-8;-.
1-6+0
F-8-3/85=5H?+0
3@16.
*5C2+.+;
6/88-6.+21/=/
4/C151+;
3,
4//.2-.4.2@H?+0
"
/7R-6.+21/,@
2/38/?-1+H
74/8H.
-
1/=/
@:5
" (
=-=-8+514.2/
),
/3*-D-8-1+H
-D+1G:
,5.-*+58+4.+9-46+:
I+C1-@.2-*ID5H?+:
F-8-0
7G.+;
(
D+58-6.+9-46+0
,5.-*+58+C,
),
D/4.+I-1+H
:/8+4.+9-46/=/
4/C151+;
(
B+8/4/B+;
24--D+1
-
4.25
)
+ 3*
.
.
3/C+.+2+4.46+:
B+8/4/B46+:
153*528-1+0
(
-65*.
,
51.
,
-071+F
,
-=-8A
)
/.D-8;-.4;
15@91/-
E,3+*+9-46/-
3/C151+-
,
/7-43-9+25H?--
@.2-*ID-1+-
42-.46/=/
3*/4.*514.25
3/C+.+21G,+
15
-
@91G,+
D511G,+
.
/C1525-,/-
3*/4.*514.2/
7G.+;
4.51/2+.4;
E6C+4.-1F+58A1G,
3*+7-I+?-,
6/88-6.+21/=/
4@7R-6.5
,
2 6/./*/,
/1
9@24.2@-.
4-7;
C5?+?-11G,
.
*+
E./,
,
/D156/
,
E,3+*+9-
-
46+-
45,/+D-1.+B+65F++
6/88-6.+21/=/
4@7R-6.5
-
@*/21+
d
+ -
,
C5,61@.G-
42-.46+,
3*/4.*514.
-
2/,
II,
1-
43/4/71G
4.5.A
3/81/F-11/0
58A.-*15.+2/0
21@.*+4@7R-6.+21/=/
74/8H.5
.
6C+4.-1
-
108
F+58A1G-
3*/78-,G
2@58+*@H.4;
*5F+/158+4.+9-46+,
/3.+,+C,/,
,
1/
2*-,;
/.
2*-,-1+
3*/;2
-
8;H.4;
2 4/F+58A1G:
65.568+C,5:
,
153/,+15H?+:
/ 1-@4./09+2/4.+
3/C+.+2+4.46+:
D/6.*+1
15@6+
+ /42;?-11/=/
+,+
4/F+58A1/=/
7G.+;
.
+./=-
2 3/C+.+2+4.46/0
6@8A.@*-
/B/*,8;-.4;
.*-.A;
8+1+;
3/C151+;
,
3*-D4.528-115;
1/2/0
B+8/4/B+-0
,
1/2/0
34+:/8/=+-0
+ 3*+1F+3+58A1/
1/2G,+
43/4/75,+
2/44.51/28-1+;
42;C-0
4 *-58A1/4.AH
21-
9-8/2-65
+ 3*-/D/8-1+;
51.*/3/8/=+9-46/0
.*-2/=+
.
15<-
2*-,;
E.5
C5D595
*-<5-.4;
9-*-C
/7*5?-1+-
6 E6C+4.-1F+58+C,@
( .
A-*6-=/*
!
.
+F<-
,
.
/8A1/-
.
-*D;-2
+ D*
.),
6 B@1D5,-1.58A1/0
/1./8/=++
( .
50D-==-*
),
6 34+:/
-
5158+C@
(3.
!*-0D
, .
&1=
+ D*
.),
6 =-*,-1-2.+6-
( .
+6€*
),
6 ;CG6/2G,
4.*@6.@*5,
,
6 3/4.,/D-*1+C
-
,@
.
5C8+95H?+-4;
,-./D5,+
,
1/
/7R-D+1;-,G-
3*-D,-./,
+C@9-1+;
,
/1+
3*-D4.528;H.
153*52
-
8-1+-
,
6/./*/-
15
4:-,-
/7/C159-1/
6*+2/0
,
1+4:/D;?-0
2 3*/4.*514.2-
42-.46/=/
(II)
/.
@*/21;
-
,
3*/:/D;?-0
9-*-C
24-
@*/21+
4/C151+;
+ 2/C2*5?5H?-04;
6 +4:/D1/,@
@*/21H
,
1/
@I-
2 +1/,
=1/4-/8/=+9-46/,
3*/4.*514.2-
(III).
/.8+9+-
/.
B+8/4/B/2
-
*5F+/158+4./2
,
E6C+4.-1F+58A1G-
B+8/4/BG
1-
3G.5H.4;
4.*/+.A
,-.5B+C+9-46+-
"
65*.+1G
,+*5
",
1-
4/CD5H.
1+656+:
B+8/4/B
-
46+:
4+4.-,
.
6C+4.-1F+58A15;
B+8/4/B+;
;28;-.4;
D8;
1+:
1-
574.*56.1/0
3+?-0
D8;
@,5
,
5
43/4/7/,
/4,G48-1+;
4/74.2-11/0
I+C1+
2/
24-:
--
3*-D-85:
+ 6*+C+45:
.
/3/81-1+;
,
21/4+,G-
*-8+=+/C1G,
3/C151+-,
(
+43/8AC@-.4;
2 3*-D8/I-11/,
34+:/8/=+9-46/,
C159-1++
),
43/4/71G
@3*/9+.A
D/4.+=1@.G-
2 *5C2+.++
6/88-6.+21/=/
4/C151+;
E,3+*+9-46+-
@*/21+
.
-*-I+251+;
4/3*+954.1/4.+
,
C52+4+,/4.+
,
2+1G
,
/.2-.4.2-11/4.+
+ 3*
.,
2/C*/ID5;
E6C+
-
4.-1F+58A1@H
4+.@5F+H
3*/.+2/3/4.528-1+;
9-8/2-9-46/=/
74/8H.@
,
3*+21/4;.
F-11/4.1/-
+C
-
,-*-1+-
2 E,3+*+9-46+-
45,/+D-1.+B+65F++
@*/21;
-
.
/C+.+21/-
C151+-
,
D/4.+=1@./-
E64.*5
-
2-*.+*/2511G,
574.*56.1/
-
8/=+9-46+,
,G<8-1+-,
,
4//.1/4+.4;
4 456*58A1G,
,+*/2/43*+;.+-,
+ D/3/81;-.4;
4@7R-6.+21/
C159+,G,+
/7*5C1G,+
,
5BB-6.+21G,+
43/4/75,+
,G<8-1+;
.
-11/4.1G-
+1.@+F++
*-8+=+/C1/=/
3/C151+;
/B/*,8;H.4;
2 /7?-9-8/2-9-46+:
/*+-1.+*5:
=5*
-
,/1+C5F++
4/F+58A1/0
I+C1+
,
5 D511G-
3/C+.+21G:
15@6
,
2 3-*2@H
/9-*-DA
=@,51+.5*1G:
,
3/C2/
-
8;H.
C51/2/
/4,G48+.A
456*58A1/-
3*/4.*514.2/
2 @,/3/4.+=5-,G:
3/1;.+;:
.
/=8541/
4:-,-
,
*-8+=+/C1/-
3/C151+-
-4.A
2/C2*5?-1+-
6 ,+B/8/=+9-46+,
@*/21;,
4/C151+;
+
2/C*/ID-1+-
+:
3-*2/7G.1/0
E6C+4.-1F+58A1/0
4@.+
2 F+2+8+C/2511/,
*-8+=+/C1/,
9@24.2-
.
/74.2-11/
*-8+=+/C1G-
D/=,5.G
2 E./,
6/1.-64.-
-4.A
1-
9./
+1/-
,
656
6/88-6.+21G-
3*-D4.52
-
8-1+;
,
43/4/71G-
4/-D+1+.A
158+91/-
7G.+-
6/88-6.+21/=/
4@7R-6.5
4 =8@7+11G,+
543-6.5,+
4@7R-6.+21/4.+
+ @3*/9+.A
4/F+58A1G-
+D-1.+B+65F++
6/88-6.+21/=/
4@7R-6.5
.
/2-*:1/4.1G0
@*/2-1A
-
,
3-*-4-65H?+0
/7854.A
42-.46/=/
(II)
+ 456*58A1/=/
(III),
;28;-.4;
2 E./0
42;C+
*-C@8A
-
.5./,
6/88-6.+21/0
E6C+4.-1F+58A1/0
5D53.5F++
+ /41/2/0
D8;
D58A1-0<-=/
*5C2+.+;
6/88-6.+2
-
1/=/
4@7R-6.5
6 3@16.@
3.
56
3/D9-*6+25-.4;
2 4/2*-,-11/0
B+8/4/B46/0
6/1F-3F++
"
E,-*DI-1
-
.+4.46/=/
,5.-*+58+C,5
",
.-/*+;
8+91/4.+
-4.A
4I5./-
2G*5I-1+-
.-/*++
6@8A.@*G
(Margolis,
1987,
*
.19).
*-D85=5-,5;
1+I-
4:-,5
*5C2+.+;
+1D+2+D@58A1/=/
4/C151+;
4/2-*<-11/
/3*-D-
-
8-11/
3/2./*;-.
2 /41/21G:
3@16.5:
@I-
*544,/.*-11@H
4:-,@
*5C2+.+;
4/C151+;
6/88-6.+21/=/
.
4:-,-
*5C2+.+;
+1D+2+D@58A1/=/
4/C151+;
(
*+4
.2)
3*-D4.528-1G
.-
I-
+-*5*:+9-46+-
@*/21+
+
.*+
=1/4-/8/=+9-46+:
3*/4.*514.25
.
7?+,
;28;-.4;
+ /41/21/0
D+15,+9-46+0
B56./*
*5C2-*.G
-
251+;
4/C151+;
-
B-1/,-1
.*-2/=+
,
3-*-I+25-,G0
2 D511/,
48@95-
@I-
15
+1D+2+D@58A1/,
@*/2
-
1-
.
*-D85=5-,5;
4:-,5
3/C2/8;-.
*544,/.*-.A
4.51/28-1+-
+1D+2+D@58A1/=/
4/C151+;
,
=D-
3*+
-
4@.4.2@-.
3/.-1F+58A15;
2/C,/I1/4.A
3/2./*-1+;
2 +1D+2+D@58A1/0
I+C1+
6/88-6.+21G:
43/4/
-
7/2
3-*-I+251+;
.*-2/=+
,
2G*57/.511G:
2 6@8A.@*/=-1-C-
.
56+,
/7*5C/,
,
,G
,/I-,
3*/+88H4.
-
*+*/25.A
3@.A
4.51/28-1+;
+1D+2+D@58A1/=/
4/C151+;
,
3*-D3/85=5H?+0
158+9+-
E6C+4.-1F+58A
-
1G:
3*/78-,
+ 2/C,/I1/4.A
+:
*-<-1+;
-
E6C+4.-1F+58A1@H
5D53.5F+H
.
109
4:/D1G,
3@16./,
2 *5C2+.++
+1D+2+D@58A1/=/
4/C151+;
15
4:-,-
3*+1;.5
./965
0.
15
I-
-4.A
4@7R-6.
,
/785D5H?+0
3/.-1F+-0
6 *5C2+.+H
+ 3*/.+2/3/4.528-11G0
7
-
4/8H.@
.
*+25;
0-1
4//.2-.4.2@-.
D2@,
3-*2G,
=/D5,
I+C1+
+ B/*,+*/251+H
,+B/
-
8/=+9-46+:
@*/21-0
4/C151+;
(
5
,
2
).
./.
3-*+/D
4//.2-.4.2@-.
.56
15CG25-,/,@
,+
-
B/8/=+9-46/,@
2*-,-1+
2 I+C1+
*-7-165
,
6/=D5
*/D+.-8+
+ 85.-1.1G-
5*:-.+3+9-
-
46+-
/7*5CG
4@7R-6.+21/0
*-58A1/4.+
3*-D4.528;H.
/D1/
F-8/-
.
/
+4.-9-1++
3-*
-
2G:
D2@:
8-.
I+C1+
/B/*,8;-.4;
E6C+4.-1F+58A1G0
@*/2-1A
4
.
/C151+-
E./=/
E.535
*5C2+.+;
-4.A
/4/C151+-
42/-=/
4@?-4.2/251+;
+
,
4//.2-.4.2-11/
,
45,/+D-1.+B+65F++
;
4/4.528;H?+-
4/
-
D-*I51+-
E./=/
@*/21;
/3*-D-8;H.4;
2+.58A1G,+
3*+C1565,+
.
5+7/8--
*511+-
(
D*-21+-
-
2 B+
-
8/=-1-C-
)
+1.-*/
-
+ 3*/3*+/F-3.+21G-
/?@?-1+;
C56*-38;H.
52./1/,1/4.A
.-8-41/4.+
,
9-*-C
6/
-
./*@H
4@7R-6.
3/8@95-.
42/+
3-*2G-
3*-D,-.1G-
2/38/?-1+;
.
.
2
D/
5-7
8-.
*5C2+25H.4;
/4
-
1/21G-
34+:+9-46+-
B@16F++
+ 43/4/71/4.A
6 D+BB-*-1F+*/2511/,@
2/43*+;.+H
/6*@I5H?-=/
,+*5
.
F-8/4.1/,
3/./6-
I+C1+
2GD-8;H.4;
D@58A1G-
35*G
:
,@I46/-
-
I-146/-
,
.-,1/-
-
42-.8/-
,
2-*:
-
1+C
+ 3*
.
45,/2/43*+;.++
3/;28;H.4;
3-*2G-
/F-1/91G-
:5*56.-*+4.+6+
,
3/8/25;
,
E.1+
-
9-465;
+ 3*/9+-
3-*2+91G-
+D-1.+B+65F++
,
6/./*G-
4/4.528;H.
4/D-*I51+-
5@./34+:+9-46/=/
@*/21;
d.
/F+58A1/
-
*/8-2/0
@*/2-1A
- 56.+21/
*5C2+25-.4;
/.
5-7
8-.
D/
3@7-*.5.1/=/
3-*+/D5
+ 3*/D/8
-
I5-.4;
24H
I+C1A
,
*54<+*;;4A
3/
,-*-
3*+42/-1+;
*5C1//7*5C1G:
4/F+58A1G:
:5*56.-*+4.+6
.
5
-
6/2
3@.A
+1.-*+/*+C5F++
4/F+58A1/=/
4/D-*I51+;
,
/3+4G25-,G0
2 4/F+58A1/
-
34+:/8/=+9-46+:
.-/*+;:
656
*5C2+.+-
+1D+2+D@58A1/=/
4/C151+;
.
5
15<-0
4:-,-
+1D+2+D@58A1/-
4/C151+-
,
*5C
-
2+25-,/-
2 .56/0
3/48-D/25.-8A1/4.+
,
/=*51+9-1/
/.*-C6/,
-
15
@*/21-
-
.
@I1/
3*+C15.A
,
9./
7/8A<+14.2/
+1D+2+D@58A1G:
25*+5F+0
-
8+91/4.+
,
D/4.+=<+-
4/F+58+C5F++
,
C56/19+2<+-
E.+,
3@.A
+1D+2+D@58A1/=/
*5C2+.+;
+ 1-
+,-H?+-
3/7@ID-1+0
6 D58A1-0<-,@
*5C2+.+H
.
/8+9-4.
-
2-11/-
3*-/785D51+-
3/D/71G:
48@95-2
43/4/74.2@-.
./,@
,
9./
2 15@6-
4,-<+25H.4;
3*-D4.52
-
8-1+;
/ 4/F+58+C5F++
+ +16@8A.@*5F++
,
C57G25-.4;
,
9./
4/F+58A1/4.A
-?-
1-
-4.A
6@8A.@*5
.
54
-
3*/4.*51-11/4.A
D511G:
25*+51./2
+1D+2+D@58A1/=/
*5C2+.+;
3/C2/8;-.
=/2/*+.A
/ 4*-D1-4.5.+
-
4.+9-46/0
1/*,-
,
/.8+95H?-04;
/.
51.*/3/8/=+9-46/0
.-,
,
9./
2 4/C151++
"
4.5.+4.+9-46+
1/*,5
-
.+21/=/
9-8/2-65
"
/.4@.4.2@H.
3*-D3/4G86+
6 25I1-0<-0
:5*56.-*+4.+6-
8+91/4.+
-
D@:/21/0
C*-8/4.+
.
511/-
4/C151+-
,
656
+ 4/C151+-
D2@:8-.1-=/
*-7-165
,
/6*5<-1/
6/88-6.+21G,+
,+B/
-
8/=+9-46+,+
3*/-6F+;,+
,
.
.
-
.
1-
;28;-.4;
+1D+2+D@58A1G,
4/C151+-,
2 3/81/,
4,G48-
E./=/
48/25
.
1-,
1-
4/D-*I+.4;
3/.-1F+0
4@7R-6.5
6 *-58+C5F++
24-:
9-8/2-9-46+:
2/C,/I1/4.-0
,
/.4@.4.2@-.
2/C,/I1/4.A
2/C2G<-1+;
D/
35*5,-.*/2
74/8H.5
-
3@16.
3.
/C151+-
,
D/4.+=<--
2
*5C2+.++
4/F+58A1/
-
*/8-2/=/
@*/21;
- 15
/.*-C6-
- ,
43/4/74.2@-.
3/;28-1+H
4/F+58A1/
5D53
-
.+*/2511/=/
+1D+2+D5
,
9A;
E6C+4.-1F+58A15;
C5?+?-11/4.A
4.51/2+.4;
F-8+6/,
+ 3/81/4.AH
2/
-
3*/4/,
@42/-1+;
4/D-*I51+0
,
3*-D85=5-,G:
56.@58A1G,
4/F+@,/,
,
+ 1-
3*-D3/85=5-.
.2/*9-46/0
*-58+C5F++
4/74.2-11/=/
4@7R-6.+21/=/
4/D-*I51+;
.
*+,-*5,+
4/2-*<-14.25
,
3*+15D8-I5?+
-
,+
3/
4685D@
42/-=/
,G<8-1+;
6 574/8H.1/
/7G25.-8A46/,@
.+3@
,
15CG258
.56+-
8+91/4.+
.
I-0,4
(1997).
5,/+D-1.+B+65F++
15
/.*-C6-
- ,
4/F+58A1/-
785=/3/8@9+-
,
/=*5ID5H?--
4@7R-6.5
/.
E6C+
-
4.-1F+58A1G:
3*/78-,
,
1-
-4.A
,
/D156/
E6C+4.-1F+58A15;
5D53.5F+;
+ 6/1-91G0
3@16.
2 *5C2+.++
+1D+2+D@58A1/=/
4/C151+;
.
-ID@
.-,
,
4*-D1-4.5.+4.+9-46+0
+1D+2+D
,/I-.
7G.A
23/81-
@D/2
-
8-.2/*-1
3/8/I-1+-,
"
4/F+58A1/=/
I+2/.1/=/
",
6/./*/,@
C5?+?-11/4.A
2 4/F+@,-
3/,/=5-.
+C
-
7-I5.A
3-*-I+251+;
4/74.2-11/
9-8/2-9-46/0
E6C+4.-1F+58A1/0
4+.@5F++
.
/C2*5?5;4A
6 E.1+9-46/0
34+:/8/=++
+ 3/.*-71/4.;,
6/88-6.+21/=/
4@7R-6.5
,
1@I1/
/.,-.+.A
,
9./
E6C+4.-1F+58A15;
C5?+?-11/4.A
=*@33G
3*-D3/85=5-.
158+9+-
"
=+3-*5D53.+*/2511G:
"
4@7R
-
110
-6./2
,
9A;
5D53.5F+;
3*-2G<5-.
+1D+2+D@58A1G-
3/.*-71/4.+
4/F+58A1/0
5D53.5F++
,
153*528-
-
15
15
./
,
9./
,G
15C258+
E6C+4.-1F+58A1/0
5D53.5F+-0
+ 4/3*/2/ID5-.4;
3-*-I+251+-,
24-:
2/C,/I1G:
6*+C+4/2
,
3*+4@?+:
*5C2+.+H
6/88-6.+21/=/
4/C151+;
.
I+C1+
E.+:
8HD-0
,G
2+D+,
,
656
*546*G25H.4;
3*/.+2/*-9+;
,-ID@
3/.*-71/4.AH
2 +1D+2+D@
-
58A1/0
+ 6/88-6.+21/0
C5?+?-11/4.+
.
/4.+=1@2
4/F+58+C5F++
+ 2G3/81;;
6/88-6.+21/
C159+
-
,G-
C5D59+
6/88-6.+21/0
5D53.5F++
,
D511G-
4@7R-6.G
*5C/./ID-4.28;H.4;
4 3-*2+91G,+
4/F+
-
58A1/
-
*/8-2G,+
+D-1.+B+65F+;,+
.
-/7:/D+,/-
D8;
E./0
F-8+
+C,-1-1+-
4/C151+;
3*-D4.528-
-
1/
15
15<-0
4:-,-
656
/.68/1-1+-
2 *5C2+.++
/.
@*/21;
- + 2/C2*5?-1+-
6 85.-1.1G,
@*/21;,
4/C151+;
.
7*5.1/-
3*/:/ID-1+-
@*/21-0
4
, b,
5
,
/3+4G25-,/-
2 8+.-*5.@*-
656
E6C+4.-1F+58A
-
1G0
+ .*5143-*4/158A1G0
6*+C+4G
,
2 1/*,5.+21/,
25*+51.-
(
*-9A
+D-.
/7
51.*/3/8/=+9-46/0
1/*,5.+21/4.+
)
3*-D3/85=5-.
+1.-=*5F+H
4/D-*I51+;
E.+:
@*/21-0
,
2/C2*5?-1+-
6 @*/21H
- 2
*-8+=+/C1/,
3*/4.*514.2-
(III)
+ *5C2+.+-
1/2G:
4/F+58A1/
-
*/8-2G:
+D-1.+B+65F+0
.
56+,
/7*5
-
C/,
,
2 8+91/4.+
*-58+C@-.4;
C159+.-8A1/
7/8--
<+*/6+0
43-6.*
4/F+58A1/
C159+,G:
45,/+D-1
-
.+B+65F+0
,
+ 785=/3/8@915;
2 E./0
42;C+
C56519+25-.4;
659-4.2-11/
1/2G,
4/4./;1+-,
4/F+
-
58A1/
-
*/8-2/=/
@*/21;
-
*54<+*-1+-
/.*-C65
-
D/
/.*-C65
- ,
./
-4.A
24-
2/C,/I1/-
3*/
-
4.*514.2/
4/F+58A1/
-
*/8-2/=/
@*/21;
-
.
*-D4.528-11G0
2 4:-,-
51.*/3/8/=+9-46+0
*56@*4
3*/78-,G
D-,/14.*+*@-.
,
9./
*5C2+.+-
+1D+
-
2+D@58A1/=/
4/C151+;
1-
/7;C5.-8A1/
/=*51+9-1/
3*/4./0
4/F+58+C5F+-0
.
*;D-
48@95-2
3*-/7
-
*5C/251+;
4/C151+;
3*/D/8I5H.4;
2 +1D+2+D@58A1/,
3*/:/ID-1++
*511+:
B+8/=-1-.+9-46+
C5
-
8/I-11G:
@*/21-0
4/C151+;
+ C56519+25H.4;
7/8A<-0
+1.-=*+
-
*/2511/4.AH
+ F-8/4.1/4.AH
.
*+
E./,
3-*-I+251+-
E6C+4.-1F+58A1G:
+ .*5143-*4/158A1G:
6*+C+4/2
,
D-C+1.-=*5F+;
4/C151+;
+
3-*+/DG
34+:+9-46/0
1-4.57+8A1/4.+
,/=@.
+,-.A
1-
./8A6/
34+:/35./8/=+9-46@H
,
1/
+ /7?@H
51.*/3/8/=+9-46@H
+1.-*3*-.5F+H
.
*+1F+3+58A1/
25I1G,
3*-D4.528;-.4;
,
9./
3-*-I+251+-
6*+C+4/2
,
4/3/4.52+,G:
3/
4+8-
4 34+:/.+9-46+,+
*544.*/04.25,+
,
23/81-
4/2,-4.+,/
4 D/4.+
-
I-1+-,
4/F+58A1/
-
*/8-2/=/
@*/21;
,
3*+C1525-,/=/
1/*,5.+21G,
.
4+:/8/=+9-46+0
5158+C
6@8A.@*1/
-
+4./*+9-46/=/
,5.-*+585
3/C2/8;-.
1-
./8A6/
*544,/.*-.A
4B/*,@8+*/2511G-
6@8A.@*B+8/4/B46+-
3/8/I-1+;
15
6/16*-.1/,
+4./*+9-46/,
,5.-*+58-
,
1/
+
/7*5.+.A4;
6 4/F+/
-
6@8A.@*1G,
@48/2+;,
6*-5.+21/=/
(
1-35./8/=+9-46/=/
)
*5C2+.+;
+C,-1-1+0
4/C151+;
4 /4@?-4.28-1+-,
E6C+4.-1F+58A1/0
5D53.5F++
.
[1]
1.-*-4
6 ,-D+F+146+,
543-6.5,
<5,51+C,5
+ <5,51+4.+9-46+,
D-.-*,+15F+;,
:*/1/
-
8/=+9-46+
,/=
7G
4//.2-.4.2/25.A
3/;28-1+H
2 *5,65:
E.1+9-46/0
34+:/8/=++
/.D-8A1/0
/.*548+
,
15C2511/0
3/CD1--
E.1/34+:+5.*+-0
.
/D
E.1/34+:+5.*+-0
CD-4A
3/1+,5-.4;
1-
+C@9-1+-
E.1+9-
-
46+:
/4/7-11/4.-0
"
*543*/4.*51-1+;
,
68+1+6+
,
.-9-1+;
+ +4:/D5
34+:+9-46+:
C57/8-251+0
"
+ 2/
-
3*/45
"
656
",
5 3*/78-,15;
/7854.A
,
.-41/
42;C5115;
4 E.1/=-1-C/,
+ 2/3*/45,+
"
3/9-,@
",
2 4+8@
656+:
6@8A.@*1/
-
+4./*+9-46+:
/74./;.-8A4.2
4.58/
2/C,/I1G,
3/;28-1+-
34+:+9-46+:
*54
-
4.*/04.2
(
+1-2+9
,
1991).
[2]
*+2/D+,G-
5*=@,-1.G
2 3/8AC@
3-*2+91/4.+
5BB-6.+21/0
4B-*G
34+:+6+
,/I1/
*54<+*+.A
+
D511G,+
1-0*/B+C+/8/=++
,
+C
6/./*G:
+C2-4.1/
,
9./
C5
EBB-6.+21/4.A
/.2-95H.
*511+-
B+8//1
-
./=-1-.+9-46+-
4.*@6.@*G
=/8/21/=/
,/C=5
,
5 43/4/71/4.A
6 8/=+9-46/,@
,G<8-1+H
+ *5F+/158A
-
1/0
4+4.-,5.+C5F++
15
1-0*/D+15,+9-46/,
@*/21-
42;C515
4 7/8--
3/CD1+,
1-/6/*.-64/,
.
[3]
.+,/8/=+9-46+
48/2/
religere (
85.
.)
/C1595-.
"
42;CG25.A
2,-4.-
",
9./
,/I-.
3/D.2-*ID5.A
/7/41/2511/4.A
35*588-8-0
,-ID@
+1D+2+D@58A1G,+
3*-D4.528-1+;,+
+ *-8+=+/C1G,+
6/88-6
-
.+21G,+
,
/785D5H?+,+
.+3/8/=+9-46+
/D1/*/D1G,+
42/04.25,+
.
./0
I-
,-*-
,
2 656/0
*-8+=+;