Файл: Дрёмов С.В., Сёмин И.Р. - Измененные состояния сознания.pdf
ВУЗ: Не указан
Категория: Не указан
Дисциплина: Не указана
Добавлен: 10.10.2020
Просмотров: 2736
Скачиваний: 8
121
C+45
,
+
"
.-
,
6./
*51--
7/8-8
,
4.58+
<5,515,+
./8A6/
3/./,@
,
9./
+,
@D58/4A
2GCD/*/2-.A
" (
8+5
-
D-
, 1996,
4
.84).
48+
4/3/4.528;.A
+4:/D1/-
4/4./;1+-
1-/B+.5
+ 6/1-91/-
4/4./;1+-
<5,515
4
3/C+F++
-2*/3-046/=/
1578HD5.-8;
,
./
3/D/71/-
C568H9-1+-
,/I-.
3/65C5.A4;
15+7/8--
./91G,
+ 3*52+8A1G,
.
'5,51
D-04.2+.-8A1/
4/2-*<5-.
/3*-D-8-11G0
3@.A
/.
*544.*/04.2
34+:/.+9-46/
-
=/
3/*;D65
4/
24-,+
4//.2-.4.2@H?+,+
34+:/35./8/=+9-46+,+
5.*+7@.5,+
6 34+:+9-46/,@
CD/*/
-
2AH
.
-04.2+.-8A1/
-
@7-=5-.
+C
7/8-C1+
,
D5
-?-
656
@D591/
!
8521G,
,
656
3+<-.
.
8+5D-
(1998,
4
.31), "
;28;-.4;
2/3*/4
+4F-8-1+;
,
/285D-1+;
4/7/0
,
*521/2-4+;
,
6/./*/-
/4@?-4.28;-.4;
+,-11/
785=/D5*;
C51;.+;,
<5,5146/0
3*56.+6/0
".
511/-
3/8/I-1+-
3*/:/D+.
8-0.,/.+2/,
9-*-C
*57/
-
.G
34+:/8/=/2
+ 34+:+5.*/2
(Adams et al., 1976; Halifax, 1979; Walsh, 1990) .
*+
E./,
2 @3/.*-78-
-
1+-
22/D+.4;
3/1;.+-
"
+C,-1-11G-
4/4./;1+;
4/C151+;
",
6/./*/-
,
656
3*-D4.528;-.4;
,
43/4/71/
:5*56.-*+C/25.A
6*+C+4
+ 2G:/D
+C
1-=/
,
1-
3*+7-=5;
6 C52-D/,/
35./8/=+9-46+,
/7/C159-1+;,
.
(
+1-2+9
,
*€,/2
, 1994).
5
21-<1-0
,-.5,/*B/C/0
45,/4/C151+;
3*-D85=5-.4;
*544,/.*-.A
3*/F-44G
*5C/./ID-4.28-
-
1+;
"
3/.-1F+58A1/=/
"
4 5@./34+:+9-46+,+
+ E6C+4.-1F+58A1G,+
4/D-*I51+;,+
,
3*/D2+I-1+-
4@7R-6.5
2 =8@7A
42/-0
4@7R-6.+21/4.+
+ 3/
153*528-1+H
6 5*:5+91G,
6/88-6.+21G,
3*-D4.528-
-
1+;,
,
/./ID-4.28-1+-
4 4/D-*I51+-,
,+B/8/=+9-46/=/
@*/21;
+ +1.-=*5F+H
-=/
2 4/F+58A1@H
I+C1A
.
./
D5-.
/41/251+;
@2+D-.A
2 <5,5146/,
"
7-=4.2-
+C
7/8-C1+
"
@1+2-*458A1@H
51.*/3/8/
-
=+9-46@H
D+15,+6@
*5C2+.+;
+1D+2+D@58A1/=/
45,/4/C151+;
-
+1D+2+D@58A1G0
43/4/7
,
3*+,-*
*-<-1+;
3*/78-,
D2/04.2-11/4.+
9-8/2-9-46/=/
7G.+;
.
G
D58-6+
/.
,G48+
/ ./,
,
9./
48/I+2<+-4;
.*5D+F+/11G-
3*-D4.528-1+;
/ <5,5146+:
D@:5:
,
3/,/?1+65:
+ 3/6*/2+.-8;:
,
48/I1G0
+14.+.@.
154.521+9-4.25
,
/7*;DG
+1+F+5F++
+ 3/42;?-1+;
7@D@?-=/
<5,515
;28;H.4;
8+<A
1-/7G9501/
=@,511G,
+ +1.-88-6.@58A1/
/3*52D511G,
4*-D4.
-
2/,
3/,/?+
+1D+2+D5,
,
+43G.G25H?+,
34+:+9-46+0
6*+C+4
,/F+/158A1G-
*-56F++
E.1/
-
=*5B/2
,
2/4:+?52<+:4;
6/88-6.+21G,
-D+14.2/,
+ 2C5+,/3/,/?AH
21@.*+
*/D/2/0
=*@33G
,
,/=
-
8+
7G
*5CD-8+.A
+ 34+:+5.*G
.
D156/
C5
.*5D+F+/11G,+
@4.51/28-1+;,+
,
*-=@8+*@H?+,+
4/F+
-
58A1/-
2C5+,/D-04.2+-
+ 43/4/74.2@H?+,+
4/:*51-1+H
34+:+9-46/=/
CD/*/2A;
/.D-8A1G:
8+F
,
1-/7:/D+,/
2+D-.A
2 3-*2@H
/9-*-DA
*5C@,1G0
+ 2G2-*-11G0
2-65,+
43/4/7
@D/28-.2/*-1+;
6/88-6.+21G:
E6C+4.-1F+58A1G:
3/.*-71/4.-0
.
56
3+<@.
A.M.
5=585-2
+
. .
6.;7*A465;
(1990,
4
.97), "
/7?-4.2/
24-=D5
+ 3*-ID-
24-=/
4.*-,+.4;
6 /:*51-
42/+:
+1.-*-4/2
",
4.51/28-1+-
<5,5
-
15
, "
2-*/;.1/
,
3/C2/8;-.
=/2/*+.A
/ 4/235D-1++
+1.-*-4/2
+1D+2+D5
(
1548-D4.2-115;
3*-D*543/
-
8/I-11/4.A
)
+ /7?-4.25
(
4.*-,8-1+-
+,-.A
3/4*-D1+65
,
,54.-*5
).
!/*,+*@-.4;
42/-/7*5C15;
"
E6/8/=+9-465;
1+<5
":
15
=*51+
34+:/B+C+/8/=+9-46/=/
+ 4/F+58A1/=/
/15
4.51/2+.4;
3*+7-I+
-
?-,
+ /38/./,
*5C1/=/
*/D5
"
<5,514.2@H?+:
8+F
"" (
.5,
I-
).
'5,51
2 .*5D+F+/11/,
/7?-4.2-
1-
C56519+25-.
3/81G,
4@,54<-4.2+-,
1-
3/./,@
,
9./
@ 1-=/
1-.
6 E./,@
3*-D3/4G8/6
,
5 3/./,@
,
9./
/1
;28;-.4;
,
3/
48/25,
. .
'+*/6/=/*/25
(1919), "
=5*,/1+C5./*/,
I+C1+
6/88-6.+25
2/
2C5+,/
-
D-04.2++
4 /6*@I5H?+,
,+*/,
",
./
-4.A
/785D5-.
4/F+58A1/0
C159+,/4.AH
.
/48-D1;;
,
-4.-4.
-
2-11/
,
/7R;41;-.4;
1-
@.+8+.5*1G,+
43/4/71/4.;,+
(
+:
1-2/C,/I1/
/.*+F5.A
,
1/
/1+
2./*+91G
),
5 */8AH
<5,515
656
42/-/7*5C1/=/
"
E643-*.5
"
3/
1-;21/0
4@7R-6.+21/4.+
6/88-6.+21/=/
4@7R-6.5
.
56
3+<-.
. .
'5.+8/2
(1931,
4
.121), "
<5,51
-
E./
/33/C+F+;
,*591G,
,+*/2G,
4+85,
;
E./
/:*5
-
1+.-8A
I+C1+
15
C-,8-
,
D*@=
4-,A+
,
3/6*/2+.-8A
38-,-1+
,
*/D5
.
1
-D+14.2-11G0
2:/D+.
2 /7?-
-
1+-
4 7/I-4.2/,
...
4 3/,/?AH
6/./*/=/
/1
,/I-.
2-4.+
7/*A7@
4 8@1=5,+
-
C8G,+
D@:5,+
,
/1
,/I-.
+:
+C=/1;.A
+C
7/8;?-=/
,
/1
,/I-.
C15.A
7@D@?--
".
/
. .
54+8-2+9
(1971,
4
.60), "
=8521/0
B@16
-
F+-0
<5,515
7G85
C57/.5
/ D@<5:
42/-=/
6/88-6.+25
".
4/7/-
3/8/I-1+-
<5,515
,
4/=8541/
. .
/2+6
(1984,
4
.191-205),
/7@48/28-1/
.-,
,
9./
3/48-
4,-*.+
-
2/C*/ID-1+;
/1
@I-
1-
23/81-
9-8/2-6
,
5 C58/I1+6
*/D5
2 ,+*-
D@:/2
-
=5*51.
/7?-4.2-11/=/
785=/3/8@9+;
.
122
*/:/D;
3@.A
E6C+4.-1F+58A1/=/
2/C*/ID-1+;
,
<5,51
/D1/2*-,-11/
+ -4.-4.2-11G,
/7*5C/,
4/
-
4*-D/./9+25-.
2 42/+:
*@65:
24H
D@:/21@H
I+C1A
*/D5
.
H7/-
*+.@58A1/-
D-04.2+-
,
2G3/81;-,/-
<5,51/,
,
+,--.
D2/01/0
4,G48
-
456*58A1G0
+ C*-8+?1G0
.
B/*,8-1+-
/7*5C/2
,
42;C@H?+:
98-1/2
6/88-6.+25
,-ID@
4/7/0
,
4/
42/+,+
,+B/8/=+9-46+,+
3*-D65,+
,
+ C159+.
,
4 /6*@I5H?-0
D-04.2+.-8A1/4.AH
,
;28;-.4;
3-*-2/D/,
15
;CG6
4/2*-,-11/4.+
3*-I1+:
*-=@8;.+21G:
,-:51+C
-
,/2
.
85=/D5*;
E./,@
65IDG0
98-1
*/D/2/=/
6/88-6.+25
4.51/2+.4;
43/4/71G,
,
.56
465C5.A
,
C51/
-
2/
150.+
3/D:/D
6 =8@7/950<+,
+4./91+65,
I+C1+
,
6/./*G-
+159-
7G8+
7G
3/.-*;1G
.
4+,2/8+
-
9-46/0
6/,,@1+65F++
<5,515
4 .-,
,
9./
1-3/4*-D4.2-11/
1-D/4.@31/
D*@=+,
98-15,
*/D5
,
4/4./
-
+.
4/F+58A15;
C159+,/4.A
-=/
*/8-2/=/
3/2-D-1+;
.
-,
7G
/1
1+
C51+,584;
,
7@DA
./
4-C/11G-
5=
-
*5*1G-
F-*-,/1++
,
3*/2/DG
D@<+
@,-*<-=/
2 3/.@4./*/11+-
,+*G
+8+
8-9-715;
3*56.+65
,
/1
24-=D5
C51;.
./8A6/
/D1+,
-
2/C*/ID-1+-,
+ 3-*-2/D/,
"
152-*:
"
E6C+4.-1F+58A1/
C159+,G:
D8;
6/88-6.+25
,/.+2/2
.
E./0
F-8AH
+43/8AC@H.4;
*5C1//7*5C1G-
4*-D4.25
,
6/./*G,+
<5,51
D/8
-
I-1
285D-.A
2 4/2-*<-14.2-
. "
'5,5146/-
65,851+-
153/,+15-.
D*5,5.+9-46/-
3*-D4.528-1+-
1-
./8A6/
21-<1-
,
3/
.+3@
D-04.2+;
,
3/
4/D-*I51+H
,
B@16F+;,
,
1/
+ 3/
./0
=8@7/6/
21@.*-11-
4:/D
-
1/0
4 56.-*46/0
34+:/8/=+9-46/0
/41/2-
.2/*9-46/0
D-;.-8A1/4.+
<5,515
,
3/
/4/7/,@
:@D/I-4.
-
2-11/,@
,G<8-1+H
(
43/4/71/4.+
,G48+.A
9@24.2-11G,+
/7*5C5,+
+ /7*5?5.A4;
6 C53545,
3*-I
-
1+:
3-*-I+251+0
)" (
-2@1-16/25
, 1992,
4
.145).
56+,
/7*5C/,
,
15
<5,51+4.+9-46/,
E.53-
6@8A.@*1/0
+4./*++
,G
,/I-,
1578HD5.A
,
656
2 6/8
-
8-6.+21/
-
+1D+2+D@58A1/,
2C5+,/D-04.2++
@4.51528+25H.4;
42/-/7*5C1G-
/.1/<-1+;
43*/45
+
3*-D8/I-1+;
.
C7*511+6
,
3-*-I+25;
6*+C+4
5@./+D-1.+B+65F++
,
@D/28-.2/*;;
+1D+2+D@58A1G-
E6C+4.-1F+58A1G-
3/.*-71/4.+
,
3/8@95-.
2 +./=-
1/2G0
4/F+58A1/
-
*/8-2/0
4.5.@4
,
5 6/88-6.+2
,
3/7@ID5;
1-/B+.5
6 3*+1;.+H
1/2/0
*/8+
,
@4.51528+25-.
9-*-C
1-=/
D+5:*/1+9-46@H
42;CA
4
3*-D65,+
,
3/8@95-.
,+B/8/=+9-46+-
(
2 7/8--
<+*/6/,
4,G48-
-
+D-/8/=+9-46+-
)
3/D.2-*ID-1+;
42/-0
4.57+8A1/4.+
,
9@24.2/
1-48@9501/4.+
42/-=/
4@?-4.2/251+;
+ @6*-38;-.4;
2 E6C+4.-1F+
-
58A1/0
C5?+?-11/4.+
.
"
*+,-1+.-8A1/
6 <5,51@
3*-D-8A1/
C5/4.*-1G
24-
,+*/2/CC*-19-46+-
65.-=/*++
.
<5,51-
656
7@D./
+ 1-.
1+9-=/
.56/=/
,
9-=/
1-8AC;
7G8/
7G
/715*@I+.A
@ +1G:
456*58A1G:
8+F
.
D156/
24-
E.+
659-4.25
+ 42/04.25
;28-1G
2 <5,51-
42-*:
,-*G
-
-=/
/4/7-11/4.+
2/43*+;.+;
,+*5
,
6/1.56.G
4 3*-D65,+
+ D@:5,+
,
I+C1-D-;.-8A1G-
3/.-1F++
,
285D-1+-
48/2/,
+ .
.
D
.
/C,/I1/
,
49+.58/4A
,
9./
<5,51
/785D5-.
.56+,
7/=5.4.2/,
-?-
+ 3/./,@
,
9./
-=/
"
D/1/*/,
"
4.51/2+.4;
2-4A
*/D
" (
5
-
=585-2
,
6.;7*A465;
, 1990,
4
.96).
+3/8/=+9-46+
78+C6/-
;28-1+-
,
6/=D5
"
D2+I-1+-
9-8/2-65
6 4/7
-
4.2-11/0
F-8/4.1/4.+
+ =5*,/1++
+,--.
+4./*+9-46+0
EBB-6.
",
6/=D5
"
+1D+2+D@58A1/4.A
/7*-9-
-
15
15
+4./*+9-46+-
D-04.2+;
" (
/7*/25
, 1997,
4
.109),
,G
@I-
*544,5.*+258+
2 42;C+
4 8+91/4.AH
-/15*D/
D5
+19+
.
*@=/0
E.1+9-46+0
6/1.-64.
E3/:+
/C*/ID-1+;
8+<A
15685DG25-.
42/+
6@8A
-
.@*1G-
/4/7-11/4.+
15
51.*/3/8/=+9-46@H
C56/1/,-*1/4.A
+1D+2+D@58A1/=/
*5C2+.+;
,
@I-
48/
-
I+2<@H4;
2 <5,51+C,-
:
/7*-.-1+-
154./;?-0
+1D+2+D@58A1/4.+
1-
3*+43/4/78-1+-,
6 .*-7/25
-
1+;,
56.@58A1/=/
4/F+@,5
,
5 9-*-C
4/F+58A1/
C159+,/-
3/2./*-1+-
6/88-6.+21G:
43/4/7/2
D/4
-
.+I-1+;
E6C+4.-1F+58A1/0
C5?+?-11/4.+
.
56
7G8/
/.,-9-1/
,
E./
4.51/28-1+-
4/3*/2/ID5-.4;
*54<+*-1+-,
45,/4/C151+;
+ /B/*,8-1+-,
2 4/74.2-11/0
4@7R-6.+21/4.+
"
574/8H.1/=/
" -
3*/
-
./.+35
4/F+58+C+*@H?+:
45,/+D-1.+B+65F+0
.
D-*I+,/4.A
+C7*511+65
D@:/,
-
3/6*/2+.-8-,
,
.*514B/*,+*@-,5;
65,851+-,
2 <5,5146+0
E64.5C
,
5 I+C1AH
-
2 4/F+58A1@H
*/8A
3/4*-D1+65
,
-4.A
1-
9./
+1/-
,
656
+1.*/-6F+;
+ .2/*9-465;
3-*-*57/.65
/.9@ID-11G:
6/88-6.+2/,
*511+:
6/8
-
8-6.+21G:
3*-D4.528-1+0
.
<5,51+C,-
,G
2+D+,
,
656
3/D/715;
+1D+2+D@58A15;
"
=+3-*5D53.5
-
F+;
",
1-/7R;41+,5;
4 ./96+
C*-1+;
565D-,+9-46/0
+1D+2+D@58A1/0
34+:/8/=++
,
15:/D+.
42/-
/3
-
*52D51+-
2 =8@7+11/0
+ E.1+9-46/0
34+:/8/=++
,
6/./*G-
3-*-4-65H.4;
2 +C@9-1++
4@7R-6.+21G:
E6C+4.-1F+58A1G:
3/.*-71/4.-0
.
+,2/8+9-46/-
2C5+,/D-04.2+-
<5,515
4 4/74.2-11/0
4@7R-6
-
123
.+21/4.AH
(
4
"
574/8H.1G,
"),
48@I5?--
F-8;,
6/88-6.+21/0
,
4.51/2+.4;
1/2G,
2 6@8A.@*1/0
+4./*++
+1D+2+D@58A1G,
43/4/7/,
4/F+58A1/0
5D53.5F++
.
D-4A
,
3/I58@0
,
@,-4.1G
D/7528-1+;
6 *544@ID-1+;,
.
43-*45
(1991,
4
.32)
/ .56
15CG25-,/,
/4-2/,
2*-,-1+
,
4//.2-.4.2@H?-,
45,/,@
*-C6/,@
3/2/*/.@
2 +4./*++
,
6/=D5
3/;2+84;
9-8/2-6
./=/
.+35
,
656/0
4/:*51+84;
+ 3/
4-0
D-1A
6/88-6.+21/
-
+1D+2+D@58A1G:
2C5+,/D-04.2+;:
<5,51+4.+9-46/=/
3-*+/D5
,G
2+D+,
,
656
153/81;-.4;
4/D-*I51+-,
B+8/4/B465;
65.-=/*+;
"
.*514F-1D+*/251+;
",
2G*5I5H?5;
,
4/=8541/
E6C+4.-1F+58A1G,
B+8/4/B5,
,
,/.+2
+43G.51+;
9-8/2-65
+ D/4./01G0
/.2-.
15
"
3*+CG2
7/=5
" ( .
5*4-8A
),
2+D+,
,
656
+1D+2+D@58A1/-
+43G.51+-
@I-
2/43*+1+,5-.4;
"
2 659-4.2-
D/8=5
,
C5
+43/81-1+-
6/./*/=/
9-8/2-6
1-4-.
/.2-.4.2-11/4.A
3-
-
*-D
/7?-4.2/,
" (
)
. .
5*.*
).
-48+
<5,51+4.+9-465;
E3/:5
-?-
1-
/.8+95854A
./0
*-B8-6.+2
-
1/4.AH
+ /4/C151+-,
=8@7+1
+1D+2+D@58A1/=/
45,/4/C151+;
,
/ 6/./*G:
2 42;C+
4
"
/4-2G,
2*-,-
-
1-,
"
3+<-.
.
43-*4
,
./
3-*2G-
*/4.6+
6 3/48-D@H?-,@
6@8A.@*1/,@
4.51/28-1+H
,
3-*2/-
/4/C
-
151+-
+1D+2+D@58A1/4.+
,
3-*2G-
E6C+4.-1F+58A1G-
3*/78-,G
,
1-
3*+6*G.G-
4/3*+*/D1G,
-D+1
-
4.2/,
+ 6/88-6.+21/0
2C5+,/C5?+?-11/4.AH
,
@I-
4/
24-0
/3*-D-8-11/4.AH
,/=@.
7G.A
150D-1G
2
<5,51+4.+9-46/0
6@8A.@*-
.
,-11/
2 <5,51+C,-
,G
24.*-95-,4;
4 3-*2G,+
6@8A.@*1/
-
+4./*+9-46+,+
3*+,-*5,+
E6C+4.-1F+58A1/=/
6*+C+45
+1D+2+D@58A1/=/
45,/4/C151+;
+ /4/7G,
*5C2+.+-,
3/48-D1-=/
D/
4/F+58A1/
-
*/8-2/=/
@*/21;
.
[11]
/=8541/
*5C1G,
52./*5,
,
2+.58A1/-
45,/4/C151+-
-
E./
"
.-,1G-
"
/?@?-1+;
,
6/./*G-
4/3*/
-
2/ID5H.
2+.58A1G-
3*/F-44G
( . .
-9-1/2
);
/7?--
9@24.2/
4@?-4.2/251+;
( .
43-*4
);
9@24.2/
4/74.2-11/=/
,
6/./*/-
+49-C5-.
,
4/=8541/
.
'150D-*@
,
./8A6/
4 2G68H9-1+-,
4/C151+;
;
4-14/*
-
1/
-
3-*F-3.+21G0
@*/2-1A
( . .
-=*57;1
);
4/,5./8/=+9-465;
+D-1.+B+65F+;
8+91/4.+
( . .
58+,/2
).
[12]
/D/71/=/
,G
1-
2+D+,
D5I-
2 /.4./;?-,
/.
<5,51+C,5
15
,1/=+-
2-65
4/2*-,-11/,
/7?-
-
4.2-
.
-B/*,5
!
.
+1-88;
.
/42/7/D+2
D@<-21/7/8A1/=/
+C
B+C+9-46+:
/6/2
,
1-
4D-8585
-=/
42/
-
7/D1-0
4/F+58A1/
+ 34+:/8/=+9-46+
.
5I-
4/2*-,-11G-
*-57+8+.5F+/11G-
3*/=*5,,G
1-
4,/=8+
3*+78+C+.A4;
6
*-<-1+H
E./0
C5D59+
.
[13]
"
.@
/4A
, -
3+<-.
.
43-*4
(1991,
4
.32-33), -
48-D@-.
+465.A
.5,
,
=D-
2/C1+68+
3*-D3/4G86+
,
3/C2/8+2<+-
9-8/2-6@
4.5.A
.56+,
,
656/2
/1
-4.A
...
-*-D
1+,
/.6*G25-.4;
@I54
,+*5
+ 4/74.2-1
-
15;
7-43/,/?1/4.A
.
./;
15D
3*/354.AH
,
/1
4.52+.
*5D+658A1G-
2/3*/4G
,
.*-7@-.
/42/7/ID-1+;
+ 4354-1+;
.
4/C1525;
42/+
=*51+FG
,
/1
4.52+.
3-*-D
4/7/0
2G4<+-
F-8+
,
3/C15-.
574/8H.1/4.A
2 =8@7+15:
45,/4/C151+;
".
7
* # ' #
&
'
&
-
2 5
$
...
,
$
.
%
,
!
%
2
!2
,
,
$
, -
!23
,
.
, %
7*5?-1+-
6 43-F+58+4.@
C5
3/,/?AH
42+D-.-8A4.2@-.
/ C5.*@D1-1+;:
15
3@.+
*5C2+.+;
9-8/2-
-
65
+ / 158+9++
D-C5D53.+21G:
45,/+D-1.+B+65F+0
.
E./0
42;C+
34+:/.-*53+;
+ 34+:+5.*+9-465;
3*56.+65
42/+,+
C5D595,+
D/8I1G
4.52+.A
+C,-1-1+-
45,/4/C151+;
35F+-1.5
15
7/8--
5D53.+2
-
124
1/-
,
3*-/D/8-1+-
6*+C+45
45,/+D-1.+B+65F++
,
@4.*51-1+-
4+,3./,/2
+ 43/4/74.2/251+-
7/8--
3/81/,@
*5C2+.+H
4@7R-6.5
.
./
15:/D+.
42/-
2G*5I-1+-
2 4.*-,8-1++
@6*-3+.A
4/F+58A1/
-
*/8-2G-
+D-1.+B+65F++
+ 4B/*,+*/25.A
1/2G-
B/*,G
3/2-D-1+;
,
5D-625.1G-
.*-7/251+;,
4/
-
F+58A1/=/
2C5+,/D-04.2+;
.
56
3/65CG25-.
15<-
6@8A.@*B+8/
-
4/B46/-
+ 6@8A.@*1/
-
+4./*+9-46/-
+C@9-1+-
2/3*/4/2
,
5D53.+21G-
4/F+58A1/
-
*/8-2G-
+D-1.+B+65F++
1-
3*/.+2/*-95.
+1.-=*5
-
F++
2 4/F+58A1@H
I+C1A
E6C+4.-1F+58A1/
C159+,G:
21-8+91/4.1G:
45,/+D-1.+B+65F+0
.
@9-./,
2-6./*/2
4.51/28-1+;
+1D+2+D@58A1/=/
45,/4/C151+;
3/,/?A
3*+
34+:/8/=+9-46+:
+ 34+:/35./
-
8/=+9-46+:
15*@<-1+;:
3/D*5C@,-25-.
D2@-D+1G0
3*/F-44
:
@6*-38-1+-
E=/
-
34+:+6+
+ 3/,/?A
2
4.*-,8-1++
9-8/2-65
4.5.A
7/8--
C*-8G,
+ F-8/4.1G,
785=/D5*;
+1.-=*5F++
4/4.528;H?+:
1-
-
;21/0
4@7R-6.+21/4.+
.
56+,
/7*5C/,
,
15,
1-/7:/D+,/
*544,/.*-.A
43/4/7G
,
656+,+
4/2*-,-11/-
/7?-4.2/
9-*-C
43-
-
F+58+4./2
-
34+:/8/=/2
,
34+:+5.*/2
,
34+:/.-*53-2./2
,
4/F+58A1G:
*57/.1+6/2
+ 3*
.
3*-D/3*-D-8;
-
-.
+1D+2+D@58A1G-
3*/F-44G
+C,-1-1+;
4/C151+;
,
+ 2G;41+.A
,
1546/8A6/
E./
4//.2-.4.2@-.
@65
-
C511G,
.-*53-2.+9-46+,
C5D595,
.
/46/8A6@
4/2*-,-115;
15,
4/F+/6@8A.@*15;
4*-D5
-4.A
1-
+C,-1;-,5;
2 *5,65:
1-46/8A6+:
8-.
D511/4.A
,
,G
1-
7@D-,
/F-1+25.A
--
34+:/=+=+-1+9-46+-
+
35./=-11G-
28+;1+;
.
D156/
,G
+,--,
2/C,/I1/4.A
4B/*,@8+*/25.A
1-6/./*G-
3*+1F+3G
.-*5
-
3-2.+9-46/0
3/,/?+
,
6/./*G-
:/.;
+ C52+4;.
/.
D/,+1+*@H?+:
2 /7?-4.2-
@4.51/2/6
,
1/
24-
I-
,/=@.
/74@ID5.A4;
2 6/1.-64.-
*57/.G
,
,-1;.A4;
2 /7/C*+,/,
2*-,-1+
+
,
6/1-91/
,
/7@48/28-1G
8+91/4.AH
6/16*-.1/=/
43-F+58+4.5
.
C
4/2*-,-11G:
4/F+58A1G:
+14.+.@./2
,
C51;.G:
3/,/?AH
8HD;,
2 4/4./;1++
D@<-21/=/
6*+C+
-
45
,
/4.51/2+,4;
15
68+1+9-46/0
34+:+5.*++
4 --
3*-+,@?-4.2-11/
,-D+658+4.46+,
3/D:/D/,
.
544,/.*-1+-
34+:/35./8/=+9-46/0
35*5D+=,G
2 42;C+
4 2/3*/4/,
/ 1/*,5.+21/4.+
+ @65C5
-
1+;
15
+43/8AC@-,G-
2 1-0
/B51+9-1+;
/42/7/ID5H.
154
/.
5158+C5
34+:+5.*+9-46+:
D-.-*,+15
-
F+0
+C,-1-1+0
45,/4/C151+;
2 F-8/,
.
=*51+9+,4;
8+<A
*544,/.*-1+-,
1-6/./*G:
3*-D85=52
-
<+:4;
+ 3*-D85=5-,G:
2 68+1+6-
,-./D/2
8-9-1+;
.
//.1-4-,
+:
4 +1.-*3*-.5F+-0
34+:/35./8/
-
=+9-46+:
*544.*/04.2
656
15*@<-1+;
2 -4.-4.2-11/0
D+15,+6-
.
48+
/7*5.+.A4;
6 +4./65,
34+:+5.*+9-46+:
,-./D/2
8-9-1+;
,
./
,/I1/
@2+D-.A
,
656
@I-
./=D5
3*+,-1;8+4A
</6/2G-
,-./DG
,
153*528-11G-
B56.+9-46+
15
56.+2+C5F+H
D+15,+6+
+ 2G2-
-
D-1+-
7/8A1/=/
+C
4/4./;1+;
35./8/=+9-46/=/
*521/2-4+;
.
*5?5.-8A1G-
,5<+1G
+ 6/8-45
,
/7
-
8+251+-
:/8/D1/0
2/D/0
,
15C159-1+-
*2/.1G:
4*-D4.2
+ 3*/9
.
7G8+
,/?1G,+
4*-D4.25,+
+C,-
-
1-1+;
E64.-*/
-
+ +1.-*/F-3F++
,
153*528-11G,+
15
+1D@6F+H
.
-=/D1;
,
9./7G
15*@<+.A
C5
-
4./01@H
D+15,+6@
+C,-1-11G:
4/4./;1+0
4/C151+;
,
+43/8AC@H.4;
7/8--
F+2+8+C/2511G-
(
/42;
-
?-11G-
-4.-4.2-11/15@91/0
35*5D+=,/0
)
,-./DG
-
E8-6.*/
-
+ +14@8+1/</6/25;
.-*53+;
.
60-
- ==
.
7G8/
<+*/6/
*543*/4.*51-1/
+43/8AC/251+-
34+:/8+.+9-46/0
.-*53++
34+:/C/2
,
5 2 154./;?--
2*-,;
E./
/4.5-.4;
.-*53+-0
2G7/*5
*5C1/=/
*/D5
C52+4+,/4.-0
.
*/2/D+8+4A
E643-*+,-1.G
3/
+43/8AC/251+H
2 8-9-1++
<+C/B*-1++
4-14/*1/0
+C/8;F++
,
=D-
/41/21G,
.-*53-2.+9-46+,
4*-D
-
4.2/,
2G4.@3585
+1D@6F+;
(Brownfield, 1965).
C2-4.1G
3*+,-1-1+-
"
5,B-.5,+1/2/=/
</65
"
2 8-9-1++
+4.-*++
(
+8E0
,
-1+6-*
, 1963)
+ 3/3G.6+
+43/8AC/251+;
+1.-*
-
6@**-1.1G:
+1./64+65
-
F+/11G:
34+:/C/2
(
D-8+*+/C1/=/
+C,-1-1+;
4/C151+;
)
2 8-9-1++
.-*53-2.+9-46+
*-C+4.-1.1G:
B/*,
<+C/B*-1++
(
5I+1
, 1968).
*+,-1;-,G-
2 4/2*-,-11/0
34+:/B5*,56/8/=++
,-./DG
15
-
C159-1+;
,564+,58A1G:
D/C
+ /D1/,/,-1.1/0
/.,-1G
3*-35*5./2
+,-H.
3/D
4/7/0
,
2+D+,/
,
.-
I-
/41/251+;
- "
*54659+251+-
"
C54.G2<-0
D+15,+6+
.
*-D+
.-:1+9-46+:
4*-D4.2
D8;
.-*53-2.+
-
9-46/=/
152-D-1+;
+43/8AC/258+4A
+ +43/8AC@H.4;
7+/8/=+9-46+
/7*5.15;
42;CA
(
3+256
,
1992),
5@D+/
-
2+C@58A15;
4.+,@8;F+;
(Brauchly et al., 1995;
-*+6/2
,
*€,/2
,
€,+1
+ D*
., 1998).
-*-9+48-11G-
3*+,-*G
,
6/./*G-
,/I1/
3*/D/8I5.A
,
+88H4.*+*@H.
D-04.2-11/4.A
4.5*/=/
=/
-
125
,-/35.+9-46/=/
3*+1F+35
: "
3/D/71/-
8-9+.4;
3/D/71G,
".
54.G2<5;
D+15,+65
+ 35./8/=+
-
9-465;
B+645F+;
45,//./ID-4.28-1+0
35F+-1.5
3*-/D/8-25H.4;
+1D@6F+-0
+C,-1-11G:
4/4./;
-
1+0
4/C151+;
.
159+,G,
5*=@,-1./,
2 3/8AC@
/3*-D-8-1+;
656
.-*53-2.+91G:
.
+
,
2 6/1-91/,
49-.-
,
5D53
-
.+*@H?+:
48@I+.
D/7*/659-4.2-11/4.A
1/C/8/=+9-46+:
B/*,
,
4/9-.511G:
4 3-*-I+251+-,
+1.-1
-
4+21G:
+C,-1-1+0
45,/4/C151+;
. .
-D@15
,
2GD-8;;
48@95+
4 /1-0*/+D1G,
+C,-1-1+-,
4/C151+;
2 45,/4./;.-8A1@H
1/C/8/=+9-46@H
=*@33@
3/D
15C251+-,
"
/1-0*/B*-1+;
",
/.,-958
--
D/7*/65
-
9-4.2-11/4.A
+ 2/C,/I1/4.A
3/81/=/
2GCD/*/28-1+;
.
4/7/-
,-4./
2 /74@ID5-,/0
.-,-
,/I1/
7G8/
7G
/.2-4.+
43-F+58A1/,@
+C@9-1+H
/1-0*/+D1G:
,
15+7/8--
954./
1578HD5-,G:
3*+
45,/0
D/7*/659-4.2-11/0
3-*+/D+9-46/0
B/*,-
<+C/B*-1++
.
/I1/
243/,1+.A
+ / .56
15CG25-
-
,/0
=*E.-*/246/0
B/*,-
<+C/B*-1++
.
56
3*-D4.528;-.4;
,
1-,58/25I1@H
*/8A
2 --
785=/3*+;.
-
1/,
.-9-1++
+=*5H.
*-=@8;*1G-
+1D@6F++
4 3/,/?AH
586/=/8;
.
48+
7G
C5
+43/8AC@-,G,+
,-./D5,+
+ /4/7-11/4.;,+
.-9-1+;
1-6/./*G:
C57/8-251+0
/715*@
-
I+258/4A
/7?--
3*/4.*514.2/
42;C511G:
4
3*/78-,
,
./
*-<-1+-
,1/=+:
954.1G:
2/3*/4/2
34+:+5.*+9-46/0
.-/*++
+ 3*56.+6+
+,-8/
7G
,
2/C,/I1/
,
7/8--
3*/D@6.+21/-
*5C2+.+-
.
D156/
.56/0
/7/*/.
D-85
.*-7/258
4.-9-1+;
*;D5
@48/2+0
.
@I1/
7G8/
3*+C15.A
1-
./8A6/
6/,3-145./*
-
1G0
,
1/
+ 5D53.+21G0
:5*56.-*
34+:/35./8/=+9-46+:
3*/;28-1+0
,
3*+1;.A
/7@48/28-11/4.A
+:
-D+1G,
3*/F-44/,
+C,-1-1+;
4/C151+;
+ /7*5.+.A
21+,51+-
15
E6C+4.-1F+58A1/-
C159-1+-
3*/
-
F-44/2
,
*5C2+25H?+:4;
2 45,/4/C151++
.
65C511G-
@48/2+;
8+7/
3*/.+2/*-9+8+
,-D+F+146+,
(
-4.-4.2-11/15@91G,
)
3*-D4.528-1+;,
/ 35./8/=++
,
8+7/
2/43*+1+,58+4A
656
7-43/8-C1G0
D8;
34+:+5.*++
+1.*/43-6F+/1+C,
.
56
48-D4.2+-
,
2 34+:+5.*+9-46/0
3*56.+6-
,/I1/
1578HD5.A
*54
-
3*/4.*51-1+-
,58//3*52D511G:
2*59-71G:
D-04.2+0
.
56
,
153*+,-*
,
*5C2+25H?--4;
/1-0*/+D
-
1/-
+C,-1-1+-
4/C151+;
2/
9./
7G
./
1+
4.58/
4.5*5H.4;
/7/*25.A
,
9./7G
3/48-
E./=/
@4./09+2@H
35*51/+D1@H
4+,3./,5.+6@
@4.*51;.A
B5*,56/8/=+9-46+
.
*+
,58/
EBB-6.+21/,
B5*,56/8/=+
-
9-46/,
8-9-1++
21/2A
/7*5?5H.4;
6 +C,-1-1+;,
4/C151+;
-
15C1595H.
E8-6.*/</6/2@H
.-*53+H
.
/8@95-.4;
,
9./
45,/3*/+C2/8A1/,@
*5C2+.+H
3*/.+2/3/4.528;H.
+46@44.2-11/
152;C511/-
.
-ID@
.-,
,
+,--.4;
/3*-D-8-11/-
6/8+9-4.2/
*57/.
,
/D1/C1591/
42+D-.-8A4.2@H?+:
/ C159+
-
.-8A1/
8@9<-,
3*/=1/C-
3*+
"
3*/*57/.6-
"
4+,3./,5.+6+
2 *5C2-*1@./,
/1-0*/+D-
,
9-,
2 48@95;:
,
6/=D5
/1
/4.51528+25-.4;
15
7*-D/2/,
E.53-
*5C2+.+;
(
./;1/2
, 1961;
6/3/25
, 1965).
154./;?--
2*-,;
@I-
,/I1/
/.,-.+.A
,
9./
.-*53-2.+9-465;
+D-/8/=+;
68+1+9-46/0
34+:+5.*++
,
3/4.*/-115;
15
@7-ID-1++
2 1-/7:/D+,/4.+
3/D528;.A
8H7G-
51/,58A1G-
3*/;28-1+;
34+:+6+
+
/3*52DG25H?5;
@4+8+;
3/
3*+1@D+.-8A1/,@
2/C2*5?-1+H
45,/+D-1.+B+65F+0
4@7R-6.5
6 4*-D
-
1-1/*,5.+21/,@
@*/21H
7-C
/=8;D6+
15
-=/
3/.*-71/4.A
2 +D-1.+B+65F+;:
.*5143-*4/158A1/=/
42/04.25
,
159+15-.
,-1;.A4;
.
56
3+<-.
I
.
1=8-*
(1996,
4
.141): "
4//.2-.4.2++
4 4/2*-,-11G,
68+1+9-46+,
,G<8-1+-,
.-*53+;
D/8I15
1-
8-9+.A
7/8-C1A
,
656
2 4.5*/0
6*-3-8+1/246/0
35*5
-
D+=,-
,
5 3-*-/*=51+C/2G25.A
15*@<-11G-
,
C5D-*I511G-
+8+
+465I-11G-
3*/F-44G
*5C2+.+;
".
/
-
3/81-1+-
68+1+9-46/=/
3/D:/D5
/7*5?-1+-,
6 3*/78-,5,
E6C+4.-1F+58A1/0
5D53.5F++
3/C2/8;-.
*544,5.*+25.A
34+:/CG
656
.*5143-*4/158A1G-
6*+C+4G
.
E./,
48@95-
34+:/C
,
/3*-D-8;-,G0
2
6/12-1F+58A1G:
*5,65:
-2*/3-046/0
6@8A.@*G
,
3/8@95-.
5D-625.1/-
.*514
6@8A.@*1/-
2G*5I-1+-
.
./
D-85-.
2/C,/I1G,
1-
./8A6/
4/3/4.528-1+-
,
153*+,-*
,
4/4./;1+0
<5,515
4 3-*-I+251+;,+
15<+:
4/2*-,-11+6/2
,
1/
+ /.6*G25-.
3-*43-6.+2G
6 <+*/6+,
,-ID+4F+38+15*1G,
/7/7?-1+;,
.
*+,-95.-8A1G
2 E./0
42;C+
*57/.G
/
.
&1=-
+
.
588+251-
,
6*+C+41G-
4/4./;1+;
6/./*G:
*5C
-
2+8+4A
1-
2 4@,54<-4.2+-
,
5 2 .-*53-2.+9-46+-
4+4.-,G
(Senn, 1989; Goldwert, 1992).
E./
8+<A
/.D-8A1G-
,
15+7/8--
78+C6+-
+4./*+9-46+
+ 3*/B-44+/158A1/
,
3*+,-*G
@D52<-04;
E6C+4.-1F+
-