ВУЗ: Не указан
Категория: Не указан
Дисциплина: Не указана
Добавлен: 23.04.2024
Просмотров: 191
Скачиваний: 1
©?^\Z eb dZdhc ^jm]hc yaud fbjZ± aZf_lbe < < <bgh]jZ^h\
± h[eZ^Z_l lZdbf [h]Zlkl\hf kbghgbfbq_kdbo h[hjhlh\ dZd yaud jmkkdbcª
< < <bgh]jZ^h\ ih^q_jdb\Ze qlh ©\ukhdZy dmevlmjZ jZa]h \hjghc b ibkvf_gghc j_qb± kZfZy emqrZy hihjZª
Klbev± gZmqgh ihimeyjguc
IeZg
Klj_fbl_evguc ljZdl
HlqZyggu_ ex^b
HiZkgZy djZkhlZ
YjhklgZy DZlmgv
J_dZ b ljZdl gZ\_qgh \f_kl_ DjZkhlZ a_fgZy
?klv gZ :elZ_ ljZdl ± Qmckdbc DjZkb\Zy klj_fbl_evgZy ^h jh]Z dZd ke_^ [bqZ kl_]gm\r_]h ih ]hjZf
Fgh]h \kydhc \kyqbgu jZkkdZau\Z_lky ihzlky \u^mfu\Z_lky h gzf <k_ m^Zeu_ fheh^pu \k_ ]heh\hj_au [ueuo e_l \k_ e_ ]_g^u± \kz k Qmckdh]h ljZdlZ
KzeZ jZkiheh`_ggu_ \^hev ljZdlZ ba^Z\gZ ihklZ\eyeb _fm ki_j\Z yfsbdh\ aZl_f rhnzjh\ Hg ljZdl fZgbl d k_[_ kh[eZa gy_l fheh^u_ ^mrb hiZkguf j_f_kehf kdZadZfb ^b\ghc djZkh lhc Klhbl jZahd ijh_oZlv hl ;bckdZ ^h Bgb ohly [u aZ]eygmlv \gba k i_j_\ZeZ Qbd_ lZfZg± Qbd ZlZfZg dZd ah\ml _]h rhnzju
± b `mldh\Zlh klZg_l b kgh\Z ihlyg_l ij_\hafhqv kljZo b m\b ^_lv mlj_ggxx gZ]mx djZkhlm ]hj ihqm\kl\h\Zlv dh`_c p_e_[ gmx ijhoeZ^m ih^g_[_kghc \ukb
B _sz _klv j_dZ gZ :elZ_ ± DZlmgv AeZy [_eZy hl aehklb iju]Z_l ih dZfgyf [vzl \ bo oheh^gmx ]jm^v djmlhc yjhklghc \heghc j_\zl ± j\zlky ba ]hj : lh \^jm] ijbkfbj__l \ ^hebg_ ± lboh keurgh dZd mldZ \ aZlhg_ ivzl aZ hkljh\hf Hl^uoZ_l j_dZ QbklZy k\_leZy ± dZ`^mx i_kqbgdm gZ ^g_ \b^gh dZ`^uc dZf_
r_dB \hl g_kmlky hgb \ ]hjZo jy^hf j_dZ b ljZdl Dh]^Z ]ey^brv gZ gbo ^mfZ_lky ihq_fm lh qlh wlh [jZl b k_kljZ beb qlh wlh \ex[ezggu_ beb qlh wlh gZh[hjhl g_gZ\b^ysb_ ^jm] ^jm]Z Hg
b HgZ gh aZ dZdb_ lh ]j_ob ly`db_ aZdhe^h\Zggu_ aehc kbehc [ulv \f_kl_ Ohq_lky hq_eh\_qblv b ^hjh]m b j_dm F_klgu_ ihwlu lZd b ^_eZxl Gh g_evay ij_\hafhqv djZkhlm a_fgmx keh \Zfb < Rmdrbg
Lbi j_qb± hibkZgb_ k we_f_glZfb jZkkm`^_gby
,J_^dh \ `bagb kemqZ_lky lZd qlh m`_ k xghr_kdbo e_l ykgZ ij_^klhysZy ^hjh]Z QZs_ \k_]h \u[hj ijhn_kkbb± j_amev lZl \ebygby k_fvb mqbl_e_c khk_^Z bf_xs_]h Z\lhjbl_l klZj r_]h ^jm]Z K bo ihfhsvx fheh^hc q_eh\_d ^_eZ_l \Z`g_crbc rZ] \ `bagb
Ihq_fm \Z`g_crbc" _IhgZ[ex^Z\ aZ [ebadbfb_ g_ljm^gh m[_^blvky qlh gZb[he__ kqZkleb\u l_ dlh ex[bl k\hx jZ[hlm dlh gZrze f_klh \ `bagb Bf_ggh ihlhfm \u[hj ijhn_kkbb± h] jhfgZy hl\_lkl\_gghklv b lh]h dlh \klmiZ_l \ kZfhklhyl_evgmx `bagv b l_o dlh ihfh]Z_l _fm \ wlhf
Ih\_kl\ g_\hkde keh`gh_ keh`ghih^q k h^ghj ih^qbg_ gb_f o ijb^Zlhqguo hij_^_ebl
JZ^hklv ljm^Z ih fh_fm aZdexqZ_lky g_ klhevdh \ ij_klb`_ b a\Zgbb kdhevdh \ qm\kl\_ ijhn_kkbhgZevghc ]hj^hklb ihklh ygghf m^h\e_l\hj_gbb jZ[hlhc : wlh m^h\e_l\hj_gb_ fh`_l ijbg_klb ex[hc ljm^ dhlhjuc q_eh\_dm ih ^mr_
;_kkihjgh dZ`^hfm ohq_lky bgl_j_kghc jZ[hlu Gh ^Z`_ b \g_rg_ dZaZehkv [u h^ghh[jZaguc ljm^ fh`_l klZlv bgl_j_k guf _keb \b^brv p_ev jZ^b dhlhjhc jZ[hlZ_rv _keb wlZ p_ev \Z`gZ b ^hjh]Z _keb agZ_rv qlh ijbghkbrv ihevam ex^yf
= L ;_j_]h\hc ,, ©<hklhdªfqZeky gZ^ ijhklhjZfb Jh^bgu b y bkiulu\Ze d
g_c ]hjyqmx kugh\gxx ex[h\v
< dZ[bgm ^he_l_eZ fmaudZ Jh^bgu y keurZe dZd jh^gu_ ]h ehkZ i_eb h^gm ba fhbo ex[bfuo i_k_g©:fmjkdb_ \heguªG_l y g_ hsmsZe kdmdb b g_ [ue h^bghd JZaj_aZy dhkfhk y jZ[hlZe `be `bagvx k\h_c kljZgu Dhkfbq_kdbf dhjZ[ezf fh]eb ]hj ^blvky gZmqgu_ dhee_dlb\u \eh`b\rb_ \ g_]h k\hc jZamf wg_j ]bx ljm^ Y klZjZeky ij_^klZ\blv k_[_ ex^_c ijbqZklguo d
kljhbl_evkl\m dhjZ[ey b i_j_^ fhbf \ahjhf ijhoh^beb jy^u ljm`_gbdh\ Ohjhrh [u m\b^_lv bo aZ jZ[hlhc \ eZ[hjZlhjbyo \ p_oZo aZ\h^h\ ih`Zlv bf jmdb kdZaZlv kiZkb[h <_^v kZfh_ ij_ djZkgh_ gZ A_fe_± wlh q_eh\_d aZgyluc ljm^hf
L_dklu hlghkylky d im[ebpbklbq klbex Ih X =Z]Zjbgm H[sZy fukev ij_djZk_g ex[hc ljm^ dhlhjuc ihe_a_g ex^yf
MIHLJ?;E?GB?AG:DH< IJ?IBG:GBY
LHQD: <HIJHKBL?EVGUC
B <HKDEBP:L?EVGUC AG:DB FGH=HLHQB?
B kdhjh a\hgdbc ]hehk Heb \ k_f_ckl\_ EZjbguo mfhed < ]emrb qlh ^_eZlv \ wlm ihjm" Ijbqm^gbpu [hev rh]h k\_lZ <k_o ij_`^_ hg hklZ\be \Zk DZd baf_gbeZky LZlv ygZ DZd l\_j^h \ jhev k\hx \hreZ M DZd l_i_jv hdjm`_gZ dj_s_gkdbf oheh^hf hgZ <i_jz^ \i_jz^ fhy bklhjvy Ebph gZk gh\h_ ah\zl©AZq_f \_qhj lZd jZgh kdjuebkv"ª ± [ue i_j \uc He_gvdbg \hijhk©Gh ]^_ `_ ± fhe\be k bamfe_gv_f AZ j_pdbc± ]^_ \Zr k_dmg^Zgl"ª ©Fhc k_dmg^Zgl" ± kdZaZe ?\]_ gbc ± <hl hgª Dh]^Z [ hg agZe dZdZy jZgZ fh_c LZlvyg_ k_j^p_ `]eZ ;eZ]hkeh\b fhc ^he]bc ljm^ h lu wibq_kdZy fmaZ©Dm^Z"M` wlb fg_ ihwluª ±
©IjhsZc Hg_]bg fg_ ihjZª ± ©Y g_ ^_j`m l_[y gh ]^_ lu K\hb ijh\h^brv \_q_jZ"ª ± ©M EZjbguoª ± ©<hl wlh qm^gh Ihfbemc B l_[_ g_ ljm^gh LZd dZ`^uc \_q_j m[b\Zlv"ª
,AZfbgdZ \ j_qb
G_aZdhgq_gghklv \ukdZau\Zgby
G_aZdhgq_gghklv \ukdZau\Zgby Ijhimkd \ pblZl_ ,,AZfbgdZ \ j_qb
DZd qZklh \ ]hj_klghc jZaemd_ < fh_c [em`^Zxs_c km^v[_ Fhkd\Z y ^mfZe h l_[_
Fhkd\Z DZd fgh]h \ wlhf a\md_ |
|
>ey k_j^pZ jmkkdh]h kebehkv |
|
DZd fgh]h \ gzf hlha\Zehkv |
|
Ex[ex l_[y I_ljZ l\hj_gv_ |
|
Ex[ex l\hc kljh]bc kljhcguc \b^ |
|
G_\u ^_j`Z\gh_ l_q_gv_ |
|
;_j_]h\hc _z ]jZgbl |
|
L\hbo h]jZ^ mahj qm]mgguc |
|
L\hbo aZ^mfqb\uo ghq_c |
|
IjhajZqguc kmfjZd [e_kd [_aemgguc |
|
Dh]^Z y \ dhfgZl_ fh_c |
|
Ibrm qblZx [_a eZfiZ^u |
|
B ykgu kiysb_ ]jhfZ^u |
|
Imklugguo mebp b k\_leZ |
|
:^fbjZel_ckdZy b]eZ |
|
|
: K Imrdbg |
A:IYL:Y
, E_k aZa\_g_e aZklhgZe aZlj_sZe G Keurgh [ueh khi_gv_ iZjh\haZ k\bkldb jh`hd klj_ehqgbdZ NZ^
KZ^ gZihegbeky rmfhf kf_ohf I_j\ @bagv ^Zzlky h^bg jZa b ohq_lky ijh`blv _z [h^jh hkfuke_ggh djZkb\h Q
<gbam \ kbgbo `zeluo ebeh\uo iylgZo f_jgh dZqZehkv hljZ `_gb_ ]hjh^Z KZygh\ I_j_^h fghc i_klj__l qbkl_gvdbc gh \_gvdbc ]hjh^hd E Ly`zeuc aghcguc \ha^mo keh\gh aZf_jL Y ijhkb`b\Ze ^he]b_ qZku gZ dZf_gghc kdZfv_ ih^ h^bgh dbf h]jhfguf yk_g_f Q <klZ\Ze y dZ`^uc ^_gv ^h \hkoh^Z khegpZ eh`beky jZgh Q
,, <klj_qZc g_ k e_klvx Z k q_klvx Ihke Mey fheqZ ihju\bklh h[gyeZ Ebex b ^he]h g_ hlimkdZeZ _z NZ^ Hg ><mebq@ [ue ojZ[j ]h\hjbe fZeh gh j_adh gbdhfm g_ ih\_jye k\hbo ^mr_\guo b k_f_cguo lZcg E =Z\jbeh ohl_e [ueh qlh lh \hajZablv ^Z k`Ze ]m[u L L_i_jv klmd l_e_`db ^Z a\hg dhehdhevqbdZ h^gb gZjmrZxl hdj_klgh_ [_afhe\b_ I
I_j_kdZ`m ijhklu_ j_qb hlpZ bev ^y^b klZjbdZ ^_l_c mk
eh\e_ggu_ \klj_qb m klZjuo ebi m jmq_cdZ I Y beb <heh^y hlijZ\ey_fky \ dZj_lm E L B kbg_]h fhjy h[fZgqb\uc \Ze \ qZku jhdh\hc g_ih]h^u b ijZs b klj_eZ b emdZ\uc dbg`Ze sZ ^yl ih[_^bl_ey ]h^u I GZijZkgh mijZrb\Ze _]h >DZa[bqZ@ :aZfZl kh]eZkblvky b ieZdZe b evklbe _fm b deyeky E
Hg_]bg g_ [ue gb oheh^_g gb kmo gb qzjkl\ ;_e Hgb >fukeb@i_j_ghkyl f_gy eb[h \ jZgg__ ^_lkl\h eb[h \ i_j\h_ hl jhq_kdh_ \j_fy L Qmj[Zg hgZ lh ihg_kzl lh lZd lh kyd _]h h[o\Zlbl lh ih\hehqbl lh ihdZlbl Dj Kdhevaysbf ^\b`_ gb_f dZd dhrdZ hg g_ lh ijhihea g_ lh ijhkdhqbe g_ lh i_j_e_ l_e q_j_a _a`_gmx ^hjh]m NZ^ H^gZ`^u \a^mfZehkv ^jmav yf \ ^_gv `Zjdbc ih[jh^blv ih jhsZf ih em]Zf b ih ^heZf b ih ]hjZf Dj Ke_au kZfb ebebkv ba ]eZa _z hgZ mlbjZeZ bo m]hedhf ieZldZ beb kfZob\ZeZ jmdhc beb h[lbjZeZ eZ^hgvxNZ^ B\Zg Gbdbnhjh\bq [ue gb `b\ gb fzjl\ = M Kb[bjb _klv fgh]h hkh[_gghkl_c dZd \ ijbjh^_ lZd b \ ex^kdbo gjZ\Zo =hgq ;m^_f [eZ]h^Zjgu Qzjghfm fhjx g_ lhevdh aZ _]h ijZa^gbqghklv [e_kd b i_gguc rmf gh b aZ ju[gmx eh\exIZmkl
< hdgZ gZiheh\bgm aZg_kzggu_ kg_]hf ]ey^_eZ kbg_\Z jZkk\_lZ Q >Z\gh gZklmibeb ^he]b_ \_k_ggb_ kmf_jdb lzf gu_ hl ^h`^_\uo lmq IZmkl Lhevdh ]hj^uc ;mj_\_klgbd j_ _l kf_eh b k\h[h^gh gZ^ k_^uf hl i_gu fhj_f F = M[Zx dZgguc keZ^dbfb gZ^_`^Zfb hg ><ZgvdZ@ qZk kimkly dj_idh kiZe Q Fy]dh_ b k_j_[jbklh_ hgh>fhj_@kebehkv lZf k kb gbf x`guf g_[hf b dj_idh kibl F = MklZeuc y k_e hl ^hogmlv ih^ [hevrbf d_^jhf :jk HdgZ gZr_]h ih^\ZeZ mibjZebkv \ yfm \ujulmx i_j_^ gbf b \ueh`_ggmx dbjibqhf a_ezguf hl kujhklb F = >ebggu_ h[eZdZ djZkgu_ b ebeh \u_ klhjh`beb _]h>khegpZ@ihdhc Q Y qZklh gZoh^be m k_[y aZibkdb dhjhldb_ b lj_\h`gu_ Q < x`ghc qZklb Bg^bc kdh]h hd_ZgZ ijb ih]h^_ iZkfmjghc b ^h`^eb\hc dhjZ[eb ihl_ jyeb ^jm] ^jm]Z Dhf_g^Zgl Gb`g_hazjghc dj_ihklb lbobc b kdjhfguc fheh^hc q_eh\_d [ue fg_ agZdhf I Q_eh\_d h[sbl_evguc y mf_e `b\h jZkkdZau\Zlv F = GZk \jZq_c ihjZ`Z_l wlh ihbklbg_ [_a]jZgbqgh_ l_ji_gb_ G H ;mygh\
[jZl_p fhc aZ^hjguc d ]_jhx gZr_fm ih^\ze LZlvygm k Hev]hxI GZ [mfZ`d_ iheh\hc ijhqblZe ih kdeZ^Zf ke_^mxs__ dhee_`kdbc kh\_lgbd IZ\_e B\Zgh\bq Qbqbdh\ ihf_sbd =
Dmq_j K_ebnZg [ue kh\_jr_ggh ^jm]hc q_eh\_d = >h \hevguc ijZa^gbqguf h[_^hf khk_^ khibl i_j_^ khk_^hf I
Hlklmigbd [mjguo gZkeZ`^_gbc Hg_]bg ^hfZ aZi_jky I
KhkgZ dZd ^_j_\h kfhebklh_ k ljm^hf ih^^Zzlky ]gb_gbx:dk ;Zamgh\ keZ\_g \ ]hjh^_ dZd agZlhd klZjbgu F =
RZ[Zrdbg k dZjlmahf gZ ]heh\_ klhye ih^[hqZkv b ]hj^h \abjZe hdheh k_[y I
<uc^y aZ \hjhlZ fu ih\_jgmeb \ijZ\h b ih[j_eb g_ ki_rZ ih fy]dhc iuevghc ^hjh]_ Q KlZy qb`_c ijhg_keZkv gZ^ kZ^hf jZkkuiZ\ \ \ha^mo_ aZ^hjgh \_kzeuc s_[_l F =
Lmqb j_^_y e_gb\h jZkiheaZebkv ih g_[m dZd [u g_ `_eZy ^Zlv f_klh \koh^b\r_fm khegpm F = FZlv meu[Zykv b deZgyykv ihreZ ijhqv \_^y ^_\hqdm aZ jmdm F = HgZ k^_eZeZ ]jbfZkm \u^\bgm\ gb`gxx ]m[m b ijbk_eZ hq_gv gZkf_reb\h E Hl ^hogm\ hg kh[jZeky moh^blv NZ^ Fhg_lZ \a\beZkv b miZeZ a\_gy E < wlh \j_fy h^bg hnbp_j kb^_\rbc \ m]em dhfgZlu \klZe b f_^e_ggh ih^hc^y d klhem hdbgme \k_o kihdhcguf b lhj`_kl\_gguf \a]ey^hf E Y hklZgh\beky aZiuoZ\rbkv gZ djZx ]hju b ijbkehgykv d m]em ^hfbdZ klZe jZkkfZljb\Zlv `b\h ibkgmx hdj_klghklv E HgZ g_kdhevdh jZa dhjhldh \a^hogm eZ g_ lh \koebiu\Zy g_ lh aZ^uoZykv : G L HkZ^Z Ijb klmi Aeu_ \hegu dZd \hju e_aml I B ly`_eh G_\Z ^urZeZ dZd k [bl\u ijb[_`Z\rbc dhgv I Djm]hf dZd [m^lh \ ihe_ [h_\hf l_eZ \Zeyxlky I <_jgm\rbkv \ Fhkd\m ba Zjfbb GbdheZc Jhklh\ [ue ijbgyl dZd emqrbc kug ]_jhc b g_gZ]ey^guc GbdhemrdZ E L >_j_\_gvdZ g_kfhljy gZ djZkb\h_ jZkih eh`_gb_ ihdZau\ZeZ ba^Zeb aZims_gb_ = =jb]hjbc :e_d kZg^jh\bq g_kfhljy gZ aghc b mklZehklv g_ ohl_e \hjhlblvky [_a ^h[uqb E Em]h\u_ p\_lu \ lhf ]h^m [eZ]h^Zjy ihklhygguf ^h`^yf g_h[udgh\_ggh yjdb b iurgu Ijbr\
Ghqvx \ ^\_gZ^pZlv qZkh\ ^\Z ijbyl_ey reb ih L\_j kdhfm [mev\Zjm Q <hdaZe hklZeky ^Ze_dh \ klhjhg_ \ijZ\h
G H Ih \_q_jZf hl qZy ^h m`bgZ y qblZe ohay_\Zf \kemo F = AZ j_dhc DZf_gdhc gZ gbadhf iheh]hf [_j_]m ijbldgmeZkv fZe_gvdZy ^_j_\mrdZ F K Iha^gh \_q_jhf lh _klv qZkh\ \ h^bggZ^pZlv y ihrze ]meylv ih ebih\hc Zee__ [mev\ZjZ E
Ihjhkev beb fheh^hc e_k ijbylgZ gZ \a]ey^ :dk LboZy jZ ^hklv beb ]jmklv ijh[_]Z_l ih ebpm fZl_jb I_kd ;_kklu^kl \h R\Z[jbgZ qmlv f_gy g_ \a[_kbeh gh gbdlh djhf_ f_gy g_ ih gye ]jm[uo _]h h[bgydh\ I <k_ g_ bkdexqZy b kZfh]h dmq_jZ hihfgbebkv b hqgmebkv lhevdh lh]^Z dh]^Z gZ gbo gZkdZ dZeZ dheykdZ k r_klzjdhc dhg_c = Fgh]b_ k ijhr_^r_]h [ZeZ gZ f_gy ^mxlky hkh[_ggh ^jZ]mgkdbc dZiblZg E < db ehf_lj_ hl klZgpbb dhgqZeZkv \iheg_ ]hlh\Zy madhdhe_cdZ >Zevr_ dbehf_ljZ gZ ihelhjZ gZ \ujh\g_gghf ihehlg_ e_`Zeb ^ebggu_ ihe_gbsZ keh\gh ih\Ze_gguc \_ljhf qZklhdhe G H
,Dhg_qgh g_ h^bg ?\]_gbc kfyl_gv_ LZgb \b^_lv fh]
$[ fh`_l [ulv _z ex[h\v ^jma_c kh_^bgbeZ [ \gh\v D g_kqZ klvx EZjbgu lZsbebkv [hykv ijh]hgh\ ^hjh]bo g_ gZ ihqlh\uo gZ k\hbo >Zc gygy fg_ i_jh [mfZ]m ^Z klhe ih^\bgv Ijh klbl_ fbjgu_ ^hebgu b \u agZdhfuo ]hj \_jrbgu b \u agZdhfu_ e_kZ Ijhklbfky ^jm`gh h xghklv ez]dZy fhy M\u LZlvygZ m\y^Z_l [e_^g__l ]Zkg_l b fheqbl G_l h[tykgbkv [_a hl]h\hjhd b ijhklh ijyfh hl\_qZc GZ k\_l_ kqZklvy g_l gh _klv ihdhc b \h ey Hg g_ kh\k_f ijZ\ ^Z b g_ kh\k_f \bgh\Zl >Z fg_ m^Z\Z ehkv k_]h^gy dZ`^h_ ^\b`_gb_ dZ`^h_ keh\h : K Imrdbg
,,L_[_ DZ\dZa kmjh\uc pZjv a_feb y kgh\Z ihk\ysZx klbo g_[j_`guc E Ih fg_gbx a^_rgbo mqzguo wlhl ijh\Ze _klv g_ qlh bgh_ dZd m]Zkrbc djZl_j E LbrbgZ gZ jZkk\_l_ g_ mk ihdZb\ZeZ Z gZh[hjhl mkbeb\ZeZ \heg_gb_ IZmkl Y _sz g_ [ue a^_kv gZ [_j_]m g_ ohq_lky \h i_j\uo eZablv ih ]heuf kdZ eZf Z \h \lhjuo g_ \ q_f =hgq BlZd y \Zf kh\_lmx dZd ijb yl_ev [ulv hklhjh`g__ E LZgd \uklj_ebe _sz g_kdhevdh jZa b dZd ij_^\b^_e Kbgph\ j_rbe ih^hclb [eb`_ Kbf
K_]h^gy \^jm] ih^me \_l_j b [Zjhf_lj klZe iZ^Zlv=hgq EmgZ [_eZ ijhajZqgZ b dZdhc fy]dbc k\_l ev_l hgZ gZ
\k_ =hgq G_ lh [ueh jZgg__ mljh g_ lh m` gZklmiZe \_q_jNZ^ GZ^h fghc rbjhdh_ ]hem[h_ g_[h b ghkylky [hevrb_ [_eu_ ilbpu Q Dh]^Z ^uf jZkk_yeky gZ a_fe_ e_`ZeZ jZg_ gZy ehrZ^v b \hae_ g__ ;weZ E EZd_c m`_ ^\Z jZaZ ih^oh^be d I_qhjbgm k ^hdeZ^hf qlh \k_ ]hlh\h E Hg hdZaZeky agZ dhfuf ^_\mrdb b dh]^Z ^\bgmeky Z\lh[mk kdZaZe _c g_kdhevdh keh\ qj_a\uqZcgh ihqlbl_evgh b \ lh `_ \j_fy ih hl_q_kdbNZ^ Y ihkeZe kijhkblv fh`gh eb hklZgh\blvky qZkZ gZ ^\Z kh]j_lvky =hgq Keurm dZd ^m[u \_^ml [_k_^m dZd e_kghc jmq_c [_`bl \ h\jZ] FZjr ;hehlZ lZd aZ^_j`Zeb gZk qlh fu g_ fh]eb ^h_oZlv ^h klZgpbb b hklZgh\bebkv \ imklhc [jh r_gghc xjl_ ]^_ jZa\_eb h]hgv ibeb qZc b ghq_\Zeb =hgq
Dh]^Z hg>I_qhjbg@himklbeky gZ kdZfvx lh ijyfhc klZg _]h kh ]gmeky dZd [m^lh m g_]h \ kibg_ g_ [ueh gb h^ghc dhklhqdb E
<hl fu kb^bf kbjhleb\h b g_ agZ_f dm^Z ihieu\_f b qlh h`b^Z_l gZk \ [m^ms_f =e H^bg iheh]bc ohef kf_gyeky ^jm]bf ihey [_kdhg_qgh lygmebkv aZ iheyfb dmklu keh\gh \klZ \Zeb \^jm] ba a_feb i_j_^ kZfuf fhbf ghkhf L
< ]hkih^kdbc ^hf Fmfm g_ oh^beZ b dh]^Z =_jZkbf ghkbe \ dhfgZlu ^jh\Z \k_]^Z hklZgZ\eb\ZeZkv gZaZ^b b g_l_j i_eb\h _]h \u`b^ZeZ m djuevpZ L HdZaZehkv qlh ohly ^hd lhj b ]h\hjbe hq_gv kdeZ^gh b ^he]h gbdZd g_evay [ueh i_j_^Zlv lh]h qlh hg ohl_e kdZaZlv E L <^jm] lZd kl_fg_eh qlh y ihki_rbe \_jgmlvky ^hfhc b ohly fh`gh [ueh jZa]ey^_lv h[ s__ gZijZ\e_gb_ ljhibgdb gh y h^gZdh \_jgmeky ^hfhc k jZa [bluf e[hf b [hevguf dhe_ghf gZldgm\rbkv ki_j\Z gZ kmd Z aZl_f gZ dZdhc lh i_gv F FZd =jb]hjv_\ ihklmibe \ ZdZ ^_fbx b lZd dZd y hlijZ\eyeky \ I_l_j[mj] hg ijhkbe f_gy g_ f_^e_ggh ih[u\Zlv m _]h ^jm]Z Dhj Y h[jZlbeky d dhfZg^b jm dhj\_lZ k ijhkv[hc ^Zlv fg_ q_l\_jdm >q_luj_o\_k_evgZy eh^dZ@ qlh[u hlijZ\blvky gZ [_j_] gh dh]^Z magZe qlh ^ey [_ ahiZkghklb ij_^eh`_gh hlijZ\blv _s_ b dZl_j k \hhjm`_gghc dhfZg^hc y ihijhkbe ^Zlv fg_ rexidm [_a fZljhkh\ F FZd
Fu j_rbeb qlh gZf m`_ g_evay [hevr_ hklZ\Zlvky \ wlhf ]h jh^_ b qlh dh]^Z y ^h[m^m g_fgh]h ^_g_] lh fu i_j__^_f dm^Z gb[m^v \ ^jm]h_ f_klh Q